Archives Scrapbooks

Ctrl-C, Ctrl-V. Rinse, repeat.

Fogg Art Museum Scrapbook, May 1973-March 1978

ARCH.2003.39, Rendition: 806562

Qwen, Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct

This image is a newspaper article from the "Section Two" of a newspaper dated May 21, 1974. The article is titled "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg" and is written by Clif Garboden. The article discusses the Harvard University's Fogg Art Museum's interest in photography and its exhibits, particularly focusing on a short-lived photographic exhibit. It mentions the impact of photography on cultural cohesion and the significance of historical exhibits in understanding the past. The article also features a sketch-like illustration titled "Photo of a gone world." The illustration appears to depict two figures, one standing and one seated, with a somewhat somber or reflective expression.

Qwen, Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-72B-Instruct

This image is a scanned page from a newspaper or magazine dated May 21, 1974, and is part of Section Two, Page Sixteen. The article is titled "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg" and is written by Clif Garboden. The article discusses the Harvard University Fogg Art Museum and its photography exhibits.

The main focus of the article is the museum's photography collection and its historical significance, particularly in the context of the development of photography in the 19th century. The author criticizes the museum's management for prematurely closing exhibits, such as the "Photographic Portraits of the Nineteenth Century" exhibit, which he believes warranted more time and attention.

The article also includes a photograph of two individuals, with the caption "Photo of a gone world," which appears to be from the 19th century. The photograph is described as having a strikingly unique casual portrait of Mark Twain standing in a rustic front porch setting.

The text discusses the impact of early photography on society, the cultural revolution it brought about, and the fascination with old photographs. It also mentions the technical aspects of early photography and how it has evolved over time.

Overall, the article is a critical review of the photography exhibits at the Harvard University Fogg Art Museum, highlighting the importance of preserving and displaying historical photographs for their cultural and artistic value.

Qwen, qwen.qwen3-vl-235b-a22b

This image is a photograph of a newspaper clipping, specifically page sixteen of the Boston Globe, dated May 21, 1974, from Section Two.

The article is a critical review titled:

Photography: Early Death at the Fogg

It is written by Clif Garboden.


Summary of the Article:

The piece critiques a photography exhibition titled “Photographic Portraits of the Nineteenth Century” held at Harvard University’s Fogg Art Museum.

Garboden begins by acknowledging the Fogg’s many virtues—the building’s architecture, its court yard, and its longstanding role in nurturing photographic interest—but he uses the review to deliver a “negative point” about the museum’s management and curation of the exhibition.

Key Criticisms:

  • Premature Closure: The exhibit was taken down after only thirteen days, before it had a chance to be seen by the public. Garboden suggests this was politically motivated, tied to the fact that the exhibit was compiled by students from “Fine Arts 20” — a course called “A History of Photography” — and that the university administration may have feared the student-curated show would overshadow or “outpower” its own “pedestrian Harvardesque title.”

  • Historical Value: Despite its short run, Garboden calls it an “excellent historical exhibit,” featuring rare and fascinating portraits of figures like Victor Hugo, George Sand, Mark Twain, Susan B. Anthony, Sarah Bernhardt, and Otto Bismarck — many of whom were not widely known in photographic form at the time. He notes a particularly striking portrait of Twain.

  • The Power of the Old Photograph: The review highlights the emotional and historical power of early photography — “the frozen second, captured gesture and pseudo-immortality all stemming undeniable from the transient interplay of light on tangible reality.” He points out how these images provide a visceral, “living reality” that connects the viewer across time, especially with the haunting example of Victor Hugo.

  • The Limits of Photography Then: Garboden explains that mid-19th-century photography — largely based on the daguerreotype — was technically primitive and required long exposure times. It was not merely “another new toy,” but rather part of a profound cultural and intellectual revolution that affected how people perceived memory, truth, and documentation.

  • Nostalgia for the “Real”: He discusses how the “built-in fascination with old photographs” stems from their imperfections and materiality — they aren’t about perfect replication, but about “gasping in reverence before the icons of our ancestral heroes.” He laments that modern viewers are so used to instantaneous, flawless photography that they’ve lost touch with the awe early viewers felt.

  • The Exhibition’s Legacy: Garboden concludes by noting the poignancy of the exhibit’s “early death,” calling it a “photo of a gone world” — not just of the subjects, but of a time when photography was a radical, wondrous, and culturally transformative technology.


Visual Elements:

  • Image: A small, captioned photograph is embedded in the right column, beneath a sub-heading that reads “Photo of a gone world.” The image is a grainy, monochrome portrait of Victor Hugo, seated, possibly in his later years, with a hand raised to his chin. It’s a reproduction of an early photograph, fitting the theme of the article.

  • Layout: The article is typeset in traditional newspaper columns with a serif font. The headline is in a larger, bold, slightly stylized font, while the byline and body are in standard newsprint typography. There are no other illustrations or graphics beyond the single portrait.


Tone and Purpose:

Garboden’s tone is witty, critical, and deeply nostalgic. He writes not just as a reviewer, but as a cultural commentator, reflecting on the role of photography in memory, history, and artistic legitimacy. The article functions both as a lament for a prematurely shuttered show and as a broader meditation on the “early death” of the wonder and authenticity that early photography once embodied.


In essence, the article is a eulogy for a vanished cultural moment — the time when photography first captured reality, and the time when a student-curated show at Harvard dared to challenge the institutional canon — before both were quietly extinguished.

Amazon, amazon.nova-pro-v1:0

The image is a photograph of a page from a magazine or newspaper, featuring an article titled "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg." The article is written by Cliff Garboden and discusses the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University, focusing on its photography collection and the historical context of early photography.

The article is divided into several sections with subheadings and paragraphs, and it includes a black-and-white photograph captioned "Photo of a gone world." The photograph depicts a person with a serious expression, standing in front of a window, with a blurred background that suggests a historical setting.

The text discusses the museum's collection, highlighting the significance of early photographs and the technical advancements in photography. It mentions the Daguerreotype, a pioneering photographic process, and the impact of photography on society and art. The article also touches on the challenges of preserving and displaying early photographs, as well as the role of photography in documenting history and culture.

The layout of the page is typical of a magazine or newspaper, with a clean and organized design. The text is in a serif font, and the photograph is centered on the page, with the caption below it. The article is accompanied by a headline and byline, indicating the author and the publication date.

Overall, the image provides a glimpse into the world of early photography and the role of museums in preserving and showcasing this important art form.

Amazon, amazon.nova-lite-v1:0

The image is a page from a newspaper featuring an article titled "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg." The article discusses the Harvard University's Fogg Art Museum and its exhibition of early photography. The text highlights the museum's popularity for its ability to capture the transient nature of light and its role in providing a tangible experience of photography's impact. The article also mentions the "Portraits of the Nineteenth Century" exhibit, which showcases historical photographs and their significance. The page includes a black-and-white photograph of a person, possibly related to the topic of early photography.

Amazon, us.amazon.nova-2-lite-v1:0

Description of the Image

The image is a page from a printed document or article titled "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg", authored by Clif Garboden and published in the Harvard University Gazette on May 21, 1974. The page is numbered Page Sixteen and is part of Section Two of the publication.

Visual Layout:

  • The page features a two-column text layout, typical of newspaper or magazine articles.
  • The left column contains the main body of the article, discussing the role of photography in art and its historical significance, particularly focusing on the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University.
  • The right column includes a captioned photograph titled "Photo of a gone world", which is placed near the middle of the column. The photograph is a small, black-and-white image that appears to depict a group of people, likely from the 19th century, dressed in formal attire. The individuals are standing closely together, and the image has a vintage, somewhat faded appearance, consistent with early photographic techniques.

Text Content:

  • The article explores the historical and cultural significance of photography, particularly its role in documenting and preserving moments of history.
  • It discusses the Fogg Art Museum's collection, highlighting its importance in showcasing early photographic works. The author notes that the museum has a significant collection of photographs, which serve as a valuable resource for understanding the evolution of the medium.
  • The article emphasizes the emotional and philosophical implications of photography, referencing artists like Victor Hugo and discussing how photographs can evoke a sense of immortality and preserve moments that would otherwise be lost to time.
  • The text also touches on the technical and cultural advancements in photography, noting how improvements in technology have allowed for more accurate and detailed images, bridging gaps in communication and documentation.
  • The article critiques the perception of photography as an art form, arguing that while it may not rival traditional fine arts in some respects, it holds unique value in capturing and preserving reality.

Photograph Caption:

  • The caption "Photo of a gone world" suggests that the image represents a historical moment or scene from the past, emphasizing the theme of preservation and memory that the article explores.

Design and Typography:

  • The text is set in a serif font, typical of formal publications from the 1970s.
  • The layout is clean and structured, with clear headings and subheadings that guide the reader through the content.
  • The photograph is placed strategically to complement the text, illustrating the article's theme of historical documentation and the passage of time.

Overall Impression:

The page combines textual analysis with a visual element to create a cohesive narrative about the role of photography in art and history. The article is scholarly in tone, aiming to inform readers about the cultural and historical value of early photographic works, particularly those housed at the Fogg Art Museum. The inclusion of the photograph adds a layer of visual storytelling, reinforcing the article's themes of memory, preservation, and the passage of time.

Meta, us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0

The image is a newspaper clipping with the title "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg" and features a photograph of a man in the center. The article discusses the history of photography and its impact on society, highlighting the work of Victor Hugo and his use of photography to capture the reality of life.

Key Points:

  • The article explores the early days of photography and its significance in capturing reality.
  • Victor Hugo's use of photography is highlighted as an example of how the medium can be used to document life.
  • The article also touches on the technical advancements made in photography during the 19th century.
  • The photograph in the center of the article shows a man with a serious expression, possibly taken during the 19th century.
  • The overall tone of the article is informative and educational, providing readers with a deeper understanding of the history of photography.

Conclusion:
The image provides a unique glimpse into the early days of photography and its impact on society. The article highlights the work of Victor Hugo and the technical advancements made during the 19th century, making it a valuable resource for those interested in the history of photography.

Meta, us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0

The image presents a newspaper clipping featuring an article titled "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg" by Clif Garboden. The article is divided into two columns, with the left column containing the main text and the right column displaying a black-and-white photograph of a man.

Key Points:

  • Title and Author: The article is titled "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg" and was written by Clif Garboden.
  • Content: The article discusses the history of photography and its impact on society, highlighting the early days of photography and its significance in the art world.
  • Photograph: A black-and-white photograph of a man is displayed on the right side of the article, adding a visual element to the text.
  • Layout: The article is presented in a two-column layout, with the left column containing the main text and the right column featuring the photograph.
  • Background: The background of the image is a light gray color, which provides a clean and neutral backdrop for the newspaper clipping.

Summary:

The image presents a newspaper clipping featuring an article about the history of photography and its impact on society. The article is divided into two columns, with the left column containing the main text and the right column displaying a black-and-white photograph of a man. The background of the image is a light gray color, which provides a clean and neutral backdrop for the newspaper clipping.

Meta, us.meta.llama4-maverick-17b-instruct-v1:0

The image is a newspaper clipping titled "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg" by Clif Garboden. The article is about the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University and its photography collection.

  • Title and Author
    • The title of the article is "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg."
    • The author of the article is Clif Garboden.
  • Article Content
    • The article discusses the Fogg Art Museum's photography collection.
    • It highlights the museum's efforts to showcase its photography collection.
    • The article mentions that the Fogg Art Museum has a number of things that can be said in its favor, even if it can't hold on to its coins.
    • It notes that the museum's management would do well to heed some of the finest exhibits taken down long before public interest is depleted.
    • The article also mentions that there's never been a more obvious case of such premature gallery stripping as the recent "Photographic Portraits of the Nineteenth Century" exhibit.
    • A thirteen-day hanging is only appropriate for Nixon or a museum show that nobody's meant to notice.
    • The article states that this was an exciting historical exhibit that might logically have been a surprise to the powers that be since it was compiled as a project by students from "Fine Arts 20" - that is, "A History of Photography" - and its impact and value were sufficient to overpower its pedestrian title, and it should have been granted a stay of execution.
    • There's a built-in fascination with old photographs. It doesn't come through in reproduction. In fact, it takes a certain mental preparedness for it to work its magic at all, but there is something about seeing original old photographic prints that startles us into believing in a reality.
    • This is, after all, the elemental basis for both fine art and popular appeal regarding photography. The frozen second, captured gesture, and pseudo-immortality all stemming undeniably from the transient interplay of light on tangible reality makes photography the perfect tool that it is for journalism, art, and keepsake.
    • Through photography we are able to gaze on the somber face of Victor Hugo. There is real immediacy in that experience. Minor White called it the realization that there were "minds behind the camera" and we can fixate on even the banal. We can fixate on detail - Hugo's attitude, his expression, his clothes - and we are that much closer to talking to him, to knowing what he was like. In a way it's like a frightening visit with the dead, but even without any fancy or romanticization, the simple truth that there was a living reality that existed before us comes home and elevates our historical perspective.
    • The Fogg's short-lived exhibit offered a glimpse of some of the knowns and unknowns of the last century. Many of the portraiture examples are pictures that Harvard has been using and leaning out for years for frontispieces - George Sand, John Ruskin, Tennyson and Robert Louis Stevenson. There was a strikingly unusual casual portrait of Mark Twain standing in one sense diminished (as we were denied an easy basis on which to relate with the images), there was, on the other hand, a heightened impact as we realized that it wasn't just the storybook people that "really" existed, but in fact, there was a whole world going on back then.
    • Fine Arts 20 may or may not have shared this critical tangent. Students of the arts, after all, can hardly afford just to think of these images as pieces of the past. Photography helped the world close in a little faster by bridging the gaps of geography and culture and ultimately, as this show reminds us, a study of photographic portraiture at a time when photo-technology was primitive.
    • As a historical exhibit goes, "Photographic Portraits of the Nineteenth Century" was less than perfect. It had about one-third the impact of the extravagant "French Primitive Photography" exhibition that toured through the MFA a few years ago, but considering its size and budget and the curating experience of Fine Arts 20, it was remarkably representative and made some important statements about photography in history.
  • Image
    • The image accompanying the article is a black-and-white photograph of two people.
    • The photograph is captioned "Photo of a gone world."
    • The image is a daguerreotype, an early type of photograph that was introduced in the mid-1800s.
    • The daguerreotype was a wonder of mid-1800's science that truly altered the lives and world view of its contemporaries.
    • Back then, almost all photographs were taken with more care than the average snapshot is today. The inexpressive yet highly accurate images made possible by the early photo processes provided people with more than just another new toy. Communication was increased and spread throughout society. What we take for granted today was part of a cultural revolution in the 1800's.
    • With each technical advance, photographic images became more and more common. That these nineteenth-century portrait photographs provide us with credible period documentation and allow us to indulge in fanciful speculation about whether Victor Hugo's soul is somehow captured on that gray image is less important than the fact that they served a similar function when they were first taken.
    • Photography helped the world close in a little faster by bridging the gaps of geography and culture and ultimately, as this show reminds us, a study of photographic portraiture at a time when photo-technology was primitive.

The article discusses the Fogg Art Museum's photography collection and its efforts to showcase it. The accompanying image is a daguerreotype of two people, which is a rare and historically significant type of photograph. The article highlights the importance of photography in capturing historical moments and providing a window into the past.

Meta, us.meta.llama4-scout-17b-instruct-v1:0

The image presents a vintage newspaper clipping with the title "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg" by Clif Garboden. The article discusses the Harvard University's Fogg Art Museum, focusing on its photography collection and the impact of photography on art and culture.

  • Newspaper Clipping
    • The clipping is from Page Sixteen.
    • The title of the article is "Photography: Early Death at the Fogg."
    • The author of the article is Clif Garboden.
  • Article Content
    • The article discusses the Fogg Art Museum's photography collection.
    • It highlights the museum's efforts to preserve and showcase historical photographs.
    • The author critiques the museum's management and exhibition strategies.
  • Photograph
    • A black-and-white photograph is included in the article.
    • The photograph features two people, but their identities are not specified.
    • The caption below the photograph reads, "Photo of a gone world."
  • Statistics
    • The article mentions that the Fogg Art Museum has a number of things in its favor.
    • It notes that the museum's building itself provides a continuing source of fascination.
    • The article also mentions that the museum has developed and maintained a working interest in photography equal to its more traditional attractions.

In summary, the image is a newspaper clipping that discusses the Fogg Art Museum's photography collection and its significance in the art world. The article provides an analysis of the museum's strengths and weaknesses, as well as the impact of photography on culture and society.