Archives Scrapbooks

The image is a newspaper clipping from the New York Times dated May 21, 1984. The article is titled "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years" and is written by Colin Campbell.

The article discusses the Aga Khan Program for Islamic Architecture, which was established at Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) five years prior to the publication date. The program aims to promote the study and preservation of Islamic architecture and urbanism.

Key points from the article include:

1. Program Overview: The Aga Khan Program was initiated to foster a deeper understanding of Islamic architecture and its significance in both historical and contemporary contexts.

2. Stalled Progress: Despite initial enthusiasm and significant funding, the program has faced challenges and its progress has stalled. The article mentions that the program has not lived up to its ambitious goals.

3. Leadership and Vision: The Aga Khan, a prominent figure in the Islamic world, envisioned the program as a means to bridge the gap between the Islamic world and the West through the study of architecture. Oleg Grabar, a distinguished professor of Islamic art and architecture at Harvard, was instrumental in the program's inception.

4. Criticism and Concerns: The article highlights criticisms from various stakeholders. Some faculty members and students have expressed concerns about the program's lack of clear direction and impact. There are also questions about the program's academic rigor and its ability to attract and retain top scholars.

5. Achievements: Despite the criticisms, the program has made some notable achievements, such as the restoration of Islamic architectural landmarks like the Mahmoud Ali Mosque in Cairo and the Alhambra in Granada, Spain.

6. Future Prospects: The article suggests that the program's future is uncertain, and there is a need for a more focused and strategic approach to ensure its success.

The article is accompanied by images of Islamic architecture and a portrait of the Aga Khan. The overall tone of the article is critical, highlighting the discrepancy between the program's ambitious goals and its actual achievements.

The image shows a newspaper article titled "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years" by Colin Campbell. The article discusses the Aga Khan's initiative to establish two schools of Islamic architecture, one at Harvard and another at M.I.T., with a $10.5 million grant. Despite the significant funding, the program has not yet commenced, leading to criticism and concern about the delay.

The article includes several photographs:

1. A building, possibly Islamic architecture, as an example of the design the program aims to promote.
2. A portrait of the Aga Khan, the initiator of the project.
3. Another building, likely an example of Islamic architecture, possibly located in Cairo.

The text explores various perspectives on the delay, including the Aga Khan's assurance that the program will start soon, and the confusion and frustration of those involved. It also touches on the broader goals of the program to educate architects about Islamic traditions and stimulate modern design within that context. The article is from the New York Times, dated May 21, 1984.

The image is a page from a newspaper article titled "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years" by Colin Campbell from The New York Times, dated May 21, 1989.

The article discusses the Aga Khan's initiative to revive Islamic architecture in the United States, which was launched in 1983. The project aimed to educate students and scholars in Islamic architecture and encourage them to create new designs inspired by Islamic art and culture.

Here are the main points highlighted in the article:

1. Project Background and Goals:

   • The project was intended to educate students and scholars in the history and techniques of Islamic architecture.
   • It was meant to provide a platform for Islamic art and architectural revival, focusing on both educational and practical aspects.

2. Funding and Location:

   • The project received $11.5 million from the Aga Khan Trust for Culture.
   • It was initially set to be based at Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T.).

3. Stall in Progress:

   • Despite the initial enthusiasm and funding, the project faced significant delays and had not yet achieved its goals.
   • Several reasons for the stall include bureaucratic hurdles, funding issues, and the need for more resources.

4. Criticism and Concerns:

   • Critics and scholars questioned whether the project would effectively achieve its stated objectives.
   • Some expressed concerns over the practicality and feasibility of such a long-term educational and architectural initiative.

5. Perspective from Experts:

   • Professor Yasser Tabbaa from M.I.T. and others involved in the program were interviewed, reflecting on the challenges and setbacks.
   • There were discussions on the importance of Islamic architecture, its revival, and the potential impact on the broader architectural community.

6. Visual Elements:

   • The article includes several photographs of Islamic architectural landmarks, such as mosques and minarets, from around the world, emphasizing the inspiration drawn from these structures.

The article highlights the complex nature of implementing such a large-scale project and the various challenges involved in fostering a renewed interest in Islamic architectural heritage in the United States.

The image is a clipping from a newspaper article dated May 21, 1989, titled "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years." The article, by Colin Campbell, discusses the stalled progress of an Islamic architecture program at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T.), which was initiated by Aga Khan IV.

The program, which was established with a $1.5 million grant from Aga Khan, aimed to educate both Islamic and non-Islamic peoples about the Islamic world's architectural heritage and to stimulate modern Islamic architecture. The article mentions that after five years, the program has not made significant progress and has faced criticism for its lack of direction and focus.

Key points from the article include:

• Aga Khan's vision for the program was to create a center for Islamic architecture, which would serve as an educational resource and a hub for research and studies.
• The article highlights the skepticism from scholars and the public about the program’s effectiveness and direction.
• One scholar, Yasser Tabbaa, expresses concern about the program’s lack of direction and the potential for the grant money to be used elsewhere.
• Another scholar, Old Grabar, criticizes the program for not focusing on the Islamic world's architectural heritage adequately.
• The article notes that the program has been slow in achieving its goals and has not attracted the expected resources or interest.
• Aga Khan is quoted as saying that the program is still in its infancy and needs more time to develop.
• The article also mentions the involvement of various individuals and institutions, including Harvard University and the American Institute of Architects.

The newspaper clipping includes images of Islamic architecture, such as the minarets of mosques in Cairo and Granada, and a portrait of Aga Khan. The article also references the broader implications of the program, including its potential impact on understanding and reviving Islamic architectural styles and its significance in the academic world.

The image is a newspaper clipping from The New York Times, dated May 21, 1978, written by Colin Campbell. The article is titled "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years."

The article discusses the Aga Khan's program in Islamic Architecture, which was initially funded by a $1.5 million grant from the Ford Foundation. The program, based at Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T.), aimed to educate Islamic architects and stimulate modern Islamic architecture.

Key points from the article include:

1. Purpose and Vision: The Aga Khan envisioned a program that would train architects to preserve and enhance Islamic architecture, blending traditional Islamic elements with modern design.

2. Stalled Progress: Five years after the program's initiation, there has been little to show for the grant. The program has not achieved its goals, and its future remains uncertain.

3. Criticism and Concerns: Critics, including several scholars, question the direction and effectiveness of the program. One scholar, Yasser Tabbaa, noted that the program has not produced significant results.

4. Aga Khan's Response: The Aga Khan acknowledges the slow progress but attributes it to the "lengthy process" inherent in such an ambitious program. He believes the program is on the right track but needs more time.

5. Challenges: The article highlights the difficulties in defining and promoting Islamic architecture, especially given the vast cultural and geographical diversity within the Islamic world.

6. Academic Involvement: Scholars and professors involved in the program, such as Stanley Anderson and François Viger, express their commitment and optimism, despite the challenges.

7. Future Plans: The article mentions that the program aims to build a resource base of books and archival materials to support its educational objectives.

8. Diverse Perspectives: The article includes insights from various experts, reflecting the complexity and the broad range of opinions about the program's direction and potential.

Overall, the clipping captures the challenges and criticisms faced by the Aga Khan's initiative to foster Islamic architectural education in the United States, emphasizing the slow pace and the need for more concrete achievements.

The image is a newspaper clipping from the New York Times, dated May 21, 1984, with an article titled "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years."

Summary of the Article:

By Colin Campbell

Introduction:

The Aga Khan, the spiritual leader of Ismaili Muslims, initiated a program five years prior to promote and recognize excellence in Islamic architecture. This program aimed to encourage modern designs that reflect the cultural and religious values of Islamic peoples.

The Program:

The Aga Khan Award for Architecture was established to highlight contemporary architectural achievements that respect and incorporate Islamic traditions. The program included a series of seminars and publications, culminating in awards for exemplary projects.

Stalled Project in the U.S.:

Despite its international scope, the Aga Khan's plan to build a major Islamic cultural center in the United States, specifically in suburban Washington, D.C., has stalled. The envisioned complex was to include a mosque, school, and research facilities.

Reasons for Stalling:

The article discusses the opposition from local residents, who voiced concerns about the impact on their neighborhood. The objections were primarily based on fears of increased traffic, changes to the local environment, and general resistance to having such a large-scale Islamic center in their area.

Background and Vision:

The Aga Khan's vision for the project was to create a place that would serve as a center for Islamic culture, education, and community activities. The proposed site was to be a beacon of Islamic architectural innovation, integrating modern design with traditional elements.

Community Reaction:

Local opposition, particularly from a group called "Citizens Against the Islamic Compound" (CAIC), has been vocal. The residents feared the project would disrupt their quiet suburban lifestyle and opposed the architectural prominence and size of the proposed center.

Conclusion:

The article highlights the broader implications of the stalled project, questioning whether the program's vision can be successfully realized in the face of local opposition and what this means for the future of Islamic architecture in the Western world.

Visuals:

The newspaper page includes:

• A large illustration of an Islamic architectural structure.
• A portrait of the Aga Khan.
• A photograph of an intricate minaret.
• An image of an ornate Islamic interior.

These visuals emphasize the cultural and architectural themes central to the Aga Khan's initiative.

The image shows an open book or scrapbook with a newspaper article pasted onto one of its pages. The article appears to be from The New York Times, based on the visible header, and it is dated May 21, 1984. The article is discussing an architectural project related to Aga Khan and mentions the stalling of this project after five years. There are several photographs within the article that depict examples of Islamic architecture, contributing to the visual context of the subject being discussed. A handwritten note below the pasted article shows the same date as the article, "May 21, 1984," possibly indicating when the article was clipped and added to the scrapbook. The edges of the scrapbook pages are visible, suggesting the article occupies only a portion of the page, and there is curling and some discoloration, which adds to the historical character of the artifact.

The image shows a newspaper article titled "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years" by Colin Campbell. The article discusses the challenges and criticism faced by the Aga Khan's initiative to establish a program in Islamic architecture at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

There are three black-and-white photographs in the article: one at the top shows the Mohammad Ali Mosque in Cairo's Citadel, the second below it is the minaret of the Kait Bey Mosque in Cairo, and the third, on the right, shows a detail of another minaret or architectural feature.

The article mentions that the program at MIT has been stalled due to disinterest or objections from some in the architecture and academic community. It also comments on the varied perceptions of Islamic architecture and the difficulties of integrating it with Western architectural education.

At the bottom of the article, there is a handwritten note that reads "NY Times, May 21, 1984." The page is part of a scrapbook or bound volume, with the article affixed to a beige or light peach-colored backing.

A book is open to a page with a headline that reads "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years." The article discusses the Aga Khan's architecture program, which aimed to educate Islamic architects and transform the Islamic world. The program has faced challenges, including a lack of progress and skepticism about its direction. The article also mentions the Aga Khan's desire to establish a renaissance of Islamic architecture and his efforts to promote Islamic art and architecture.

The image shows an open page from a newspaper or magazine, featuring an article titled "Aga Khan's U.S. Architecture Project Is Stalled After 5 Years". The article is authored by Colin Campbell, dated May 21, 1984, and appears to be from The New York Times.

Key Elements of the Image:

1. Headline:

   • The headline is prominently displayed at the top of the page, indicating the subject matter: the stagnation of the Aga Khan's U.S. architecture project after five years.

2. Photographic Collage:

   • The article includes a collage of photographs showcasing architectural elements and a portrait:
     • Top-left photograph: A detailed image of a mosque, likely the Mohammed Ali Mosque in Cairo, which is referenced in the article as an example of Islamic architecture.
     • Bottom-left photograph: A close-up of architectural details, possibly a minaret or intricate stonework.
     • Center-right photograph: A portrait of a man, presumably Aga Khan, the central figure associated with the project.
     • Top-right photograph: Another architectural image, possibly of a different mosque or minaret, with a dome and intricate design.

3. Text Content:

   • The article discusses the Aga Khan Program of Islamic Architecture at MIT, highlighting its goals, challenges, and current status after five years.
   • Key points from the article include:
     • The program was established to educate students in Islamic architecture, focusing on the preservation and study of Islamic architectural heritage.
     • Despite initial enthusiasm, the program has faced delays and challenges, with progress being slower than anticipated.
     • The Aga Khan is quoted, expressing disappointment with the slow progress and emphasizing the need for more creative solutions.
     • The article references the Legitimacy Process, a framework used to evaluate the program's progress, and notes that it has been "extremely lengthy."

4. Handwritten Note:

   • At the bottom of the page, there is a handwritten note that reads "MY TIME MAY 21, 1984", likely indicating when the article was read or annotated.

5. Layout and Design:

   • The page has a classic newspaper layout, with a mix of text and images.
   • The left margin includes a vertical column with additional text, possibly from a sidebar or related article.
   • The overall design is clean and structured, typical of a newspaper or magazine from the 1980s.

Summary:

The image depicts a newspaper or magazine page featuring an article about the stalled progress of the Aga Khan's U.S. architecture project at MIT. The article includes a collage of photographs of Islamic architecture, a portrait of Aga Khan, and detailed text discussing the program's challenges and the Aga Khan's perspective on its future. A handwritten note at the bottom indicates the date the article was read or annotated. The layout and design reflect a typical newspaper format from the mid-1980s.