Archives Scrapbooks

The image is a scanned page from a newspaper, specifically the New England Newslip, dated May 22, 1983. The main article is titled "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case" and is written by Peter P. Doktor. The article discusses a legal case involving the estate of Scofield Thayer, a wealthy art collector who died in 1982. The case revolves around the dispute over Thayer's art collection, which includes valuable pieces such as works by Picasso, Matisse, and others. The Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Fogg Art Museum are involved in the case, with both institutions claiming rights to the collection.

Key points from the article include:

• The case will be heard in a state court in Worcester, MA.
• The dispute centers on whether the artworks should be permanently displayed or if they can be loaned out.
• The collection includes notable works like Matisse's "Goldfish" and Picasso's "Mother and Child."
• The collection is valued at approximately $14 million.
• The article also mentions other beneficiaries and the complexities of the will's language.

Additionally, there is a photograph of the Scofield Thayer gravesite in Rural Cemetery on Grove Street. The article also includes a smaller image of a map with stars marking specific locations. The layout of the page includes the main article text, images, and a smaller article or continuation at the bottom.

The image shows a newspaper clipping from the Sunday Telegram, dated May 22, 1983, with the headline "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case." The article discusses an upcoming court case where a Worcester Probate Court judge will rule on the disposition of an art collection worth an estimated $14 million, bequeathed by the late Charles E. Thayer. The collection includes works by artists such as Albert Bierstadt, Thomas Cole, and John Singer Sargent, with the majority intended for the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. The article explores the potential outcomes and the legal framework surrounding the bequest, as well as the historical context of the Thayer family's contributions to cultural institutions. Additionally, there is an image of the Bootfoot Thayer gravesite in Rural Cemetery, and a portrait of Peter P. Donker, identified as a cultural figure. The clipping also includes a section from July 1, 1983, detailing the resolution of the case, with a photograph of Charles E. Thayer's home, now the American Antiquarian Society, and an image of the grave of Charles E. Thayer. The article concludes with the court's decision to uphold Thayer's bequest to the Fogg and Metropolitan museums, and provides details on the artworks and their future display.

The image shows a newspaper article from May 22, 1983, titled "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case." The article discusses a legal case involving the estate of Thayer Thayer, an art collector, and his bequest of various artworks to several museums.

Key points from the article:

1. Court Case Details:

   • The Worcester Probate Court will hear the case regarding a bequest of artworks worth approximately $14 million.
   • Robert J. Thayer, the executor, has brought the case to the court before the will is executed under the will of Sofia Thayer.

2. Artworks and Museums:

   • The executor wants to know if the museums, particularly the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University and the Metropolitan Museum of Art, can retain ownership of the artworks.
   • The Thayer collection includes over 500 paintings, drawings, sculptures, and decorative arts, valued at $14.2 million.
   • The estate includes other valuable items like books, furniture, and works of art stored at the Worcester Storage Co.

3. Specific Artworks:

   • Notable artworks include works by Henri Matisse, Pablo Picasso, and others. For example, Picasso's "Girl Before a Mirror" is valued at $1.7 million.
   • The collection also includes significant pieces by artists like Henri Matisse's "Dance with Caprices," valued at $3 million.

4. Legal Argument:

   • Worcester lawyer John O. Mirick argues that the Thayer estate's bequests are intended for permanent exhibitions at the museums, and the museums should be allowed to retain ownership.
   • The executor wants to know if the museums can retain the artworks permanently or if they are only permitted to display them temporarily.

5. Estate Details:

   • The Thayer estate includes an extensive inventory listing various artworks, including several famous and valuable pieces.

6. Additional Context:

   • The estate includes items like Thayer's rural country home and extensive personal library, along with other decorative and furniture items.

The article highlights the complexities and high value of the artworks involved, along with the legal and ethical considerations surrounding their bequests to museums.

The image contains two newspaper clippings, both related to a legal case concerning the art collection of the estate of Scofield Thayer.

Top Clipping (May 22, 1983)

Title: "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case"

• Content:
  • The Worcester Probate Court is set to hear a case involving the estate of Scofield Thayer, who left his collection of artworks to the Metropolitan and Fogg Art Museums.
  • The executor of Thayer’s will, Robert J. Morgan of the Morgan Guaranty Trust Co. of New York, is being asked to provide permanent homes for the artworks.
  • Thayer's will specifies that the Fogg and Metropolitan Museums "shall accept" his gift of a "permanent exhibition."
  • The Thayer estate is valued at $14.2 million, including paintings, sculptures, and decorative arts.
  • The collection includes 585 paintings, valued at $14.2 million, and other items such as furniture and books.
  • The executor is uncertain whether the museums are required to retain ownership of all items or if they can loan them out.
  • The case involves the interpretation of Thayer’s will, particularly the phrase "permanent exhibition," and the executor’s understanding of whether the museums should own the art or just display it.

Bottom Clipping (July 1, 1983)

Title: Not specified, but it appears to be a follow-up or related article.

• Content:
  • This clipping shows a photograph of the Scofield Thayer grave site in Rural Cemetery, including a gravestone and the surrounding area.
  • The article likely discusses the details of the estate, the art collection, and the ongoing legal proceedings.
  • The accompanying text is not fully visible, but it references the estate's inventory and the artworks' valuation.

Additional Notes:

• Photographs:

  • The top clipping includes a black-and-white image of the Thayer grave site in the Rural Cemetery.
  • The bottom clipping also contains a black-and-white photo of the same grave site with additional details.

• Articles:

  • The clippings are from the New England Newsclip and the Sunday Telegram, both based in Worcester, MA.
  • The articles provide insights into the legal and logistical challenges of managing a significant art collection under the terms of a will.

Overall, these clippings detail the legal proceedings and complexities surrounding the distribution and management of Scofield Thayer's extensive art collection.

The image contains two newspaper clippings from 1983, each detailing different aspects of an art-bequest case involving the estate of Scofield Thayer.

Top Clipping (May 22, 1983, New England Newsclip, Sunday Telegram, Worcester, MA):

• Headline: "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case"
• Main Story: The Worcester Probate Court is scheduled to hear a case involving the bequest of Scofield Thayer's art collection, estimated to be worth $14 million. Thayer, who died in 1982, left his collection to the Morgan Guaranty Trust Co. of New York to be distributed among the Fogg Art Museum, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and the Worcester Art Museum.
• Details of the Estate:
  • The estate includes over 500 paintings, drawings, and sculptures.
  • Notable pieces include works by Henri Matisse, Pablo Picasso, and Edgar Degas.
  • The estate's total value is approximately $21.5 million, including a collection of books, letters, and securities.
  • The Thayer estate also includes his country home in Edgartown, Massachusetts, and other properties.
• Legal Issues:
  • The executor of the estate, Robert J. Morgan, is seeking court instructions on how to distribute the art collection.
  • There is a question of whether the art should stay in Worcester or be distributed to the other museums.
  • Thayer's will specifies that the Fogg and Metropolitan museums should accept the art, but Worcester is unsure if they should retain the art or sell it.

Bottom Clipping (July 1, 1983, New England Newsclip, Harvard University Gazette):

• Headline: [No headline visible, but it appears to be about the same art-bequest case.]
• Main Story:
  • Focuses on the art collection and the dispute over the distribution.
  • The Worcester Art Museum is considering whether to accept the art collection or sell it.
  • The collection includes pieces such as "La Danse aux Capucines" by Henri Matisse, valued at $2.5 million, and "Mother and Child" by Pablo Picasso, valued at $1.7 million.
  • The Worcester Art Museum has filed a petition to keep the collection in Worcester, arguing it is in the public's interest.
  • The Worcester Art Museum has also offered to display the collection in its entirety if allowed, with the possibility of some pieces being loaned to other museums.

Both clippings highlight the legal and financial complexities surrounding the distribution of Scofield Thayer's significant art collection and the potential impact on the Worcester Art Museum and other institutions.

The image contains two newspaper articles from different dates discussing a legal case involving the bequest of artwork by the late Scofield Thayer.

First Article (Top Half) - "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case"

Date: May 22, 1983

Summary:
The article reports on a Worcester Probate Court case concerning the estate of Scofield Thayer, valued at approximately $14 million. Thayer, who died in 1982, left behind a significant art collection, including works by famous artists such as Egon Schiele and Pablo Picasso. The Morgan Guaranty Trust Co. of New York, the executor of Thayer's estate, is seeking court instructions on whether the artworks should be permanently loaned to the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York and the Worcester Art Museum in Massachusetts.

The executor wants to ensure that the museums will retain the artworks indefinitely, as per Thayer’s wishes. The article mentions that Thayer had initially loaned parts of his collection to these museums, including 58 paintings appraised at $11.2 million. It also highlights a rare Beardsley drawing valued at $54,100 and a collection of manuscripts and books valued at $313,910.

Second Article (Bottom Half) - "Can They Stay?"

Date: July 1, 1983

Summary:
This article provides further details on the ongoing court case about the Thayer estate. It discusses the potential fate of the art collection, including the significant works intended for the Worcester Art Museum and the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The article emphasizes the importance of the permanent exhibition of these works.

Additionally, it mentions that the inventory of Thayer’s estate includes:

• Paintings, drawings, etchings, and sculptures valued at $11.7 million.
• Items like a Picasso portrait and a Renoir painting valued at $760,000 and $800,000 respectively.
• Other valuable items such as a Matisse oil painting valued at $900,000.

The article also notes that the estate includes a variety of other objects like books, furniture, and decorative arts, some of which are stored in a warehouse on Pleasant Street.

Overall, the articles detail the legal and logistical complexities of fulfilling Scofield Thayer's bequest, focusing on the significant cultural value of the artworks involved.

This is an image of a newspaper clipping from the "Sunday Telegram" dated May 22, 1983, from Worcester, MA. The headline reads "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case." Below the headline, there are two columns of text pertaining to this story concerning an art bequest.

In the lower half of the image, there is also a smaller section with a headline that reads "Base Hails," below which is a black and white photograph showing a group of people in what appears to be a celebratory moment. They are near an American flag, which suggests a patriotic theme or event. The text below this photo is not completely visible, but it gives some additional information related to the photograph.

The newspaper article mentions different art pieces, such as a "26-foot-long temple sculpture of Vishnu," and the involvement of various institutions, including the Worcester Art Museum and the Fogg Art Museum. There also appears to be some discussion of the financial appraisal of the art pieces.

On the right side of the image, there is a vertical column skipping the item at the top with the blurred face with the label "Culture" and author credit to Peter P. Donker. There's also a small section labeled "Other Beneficiaries" and a list of locations that are mentioned in connection with the art bequest case.

Just above the lower section, there's a small photograph of a stone grave or monument situated in a calm, outdoor setting.

Lastly, along the bottom of the clipping, the newspaper's name "NEW ENGLAND NEWSCLIP" is present.

The image shows a scrapbook or a collection of newspaper clippings on a page. There are two main articles:

1. The top article is titled "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case" from the New England Newsclip, Sunday Telegram, Worcester, MA, dated May 22, 1983. It discusses a legal case regarding the bequest of art worth an estimated $14 million. The article centers on a dispute over whether certain artworks can be permanently exhibited at the Metropolitan Museum or if the restrictions imposed in the will can be enforced. It mentions the Thayer family, specific artworks, and appraisals. A small black-and-white photo of the Scofield Thayer gravesite in Rural Cemetery on Grove Street is included in the middle of the article. There is also a small photo of the article’s author or a figure related to the article, but the face is obscured.

2. The bottom article, dated July 1, 1983, is a black-and-white photograph clipping from the New England Newsclip and Sunday Gazette, Worcester, MA. It depicts a person standing near a large grave marker with ribbons or bunting in the background. The text explains that the photo shows the restoration ceremony of the grave of Captain David Sears, noting the involvement of various individuals and historical societies.

The clippings are glued or taped onto a beige scrapbook page, with typed or printed labels showing dates and publication names. The overall content focuses on art, historical preservation, and a legal case related to art bequests.

The image is a scanned page from a newspaper, dated May 22, 1983. The article discusses a legal case involving the estate of Scofield Thayer, a prominent art collector and benefactor. The article is titled "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case" and is accompanied by a photograph of a gravestone.

The article explains that Thayer's will bequeathed his entire estate, valued at $14 million, to the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University. However, the executor of the will, Robert J. Whipple, a Worcester lawyer, has brought a case to the Worcester Probate Court to determine the permanence of the bequest. Thayer's will specified that his art collection should be "permanently exhibited," but the executor is seeking clarification on whether this means the art must be on display at all times or if it can be stored in a museum's collection.

The article also mentions that Thayer's art collection includes works by various artists, such as Henri Matisse, Pablo Picasso, and Paul Cézanne, and that the collection is appraised at $17 million. The executor is concerned that the Fogg Art Museum may not have the resources to permanently exhibit the entire collection, as it is already housed in a storage facility.

The article further discusses the legal implications of the case, including the potential for the court to order the bequest to be modified or for the executor to seek alternative arrangements for the art collection. The article concludes by noting that the case is expected to be heard on Tuesday and that the outcome could have significant implications for the future of Thayer's art collection.

The image shows a page from a newspaper or news clipping dated May 22, 1983, from the New England Newsclip Sunday Telegram based in Worcester, MA. The article is titled "Court to Hear Art-Bequest Case" and is authored by Peter P. Donker, a Telegram reporter.

Content Overview:

The article discusses a legal case involving the estate of Martha Thayer, who left a substantial art collection valued at an estimated $14 million in her will. The key points covered in the article include:

1. The Art Collection:

• The collection includes paintings, drawings, prints, and sculpture, with notable pieces such as:
  • 58 paintings, drawings, etchings, and sculpture valued at $14,221,279.
  • 21 large-scale bronze sculptures by Gaston Lachaux, valued at $1,000,000.
  • A series of Aubrey Beardsley drawings valued at $202,000.
  • The Thayer Collection, including 19th-century art, valued at $12,000,000.
  • Securities and a collection of books, letters, and manuscripts valued at $7,721,396.
• The total value of the estate is $14 million.

2. The Legal Dispute:

• The executor of the estate, Robert J. Whipple, a Worcester lawyer representing the Morgan Guaranty Trust Co. of New York, is seeking court approval for the disposition of the art.
• The Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Fogg Art Museum in Cambridge, MA, are named as beneficiaries under the will.
• The court will decide whether the museums can retain ownership of the art or if it must be loaned to them under specific conditions.

3. Key Legal and Financial Details:

• The executor argues that the museums should be required to have permanent exhibitions of the art, but the museums contest this, stating they only have intentions to display the works.
• The Worcester Art Museum is also mentioned as a potential beneficiary, but the article notes that the collection was already on long-term loan to the museum since the 1930s.
• The Thayer Collection includes works by notable artists such as Henri Matisse, Pablo Picasso, Auguste Renoir, Paul Cézanne, Peter Paul Rubens, Abraham Dürer, Gustav Klimt, Oskar Kokoschka, Ignaz Gauguin, and Maurice de Vlaminck.

4. Visual Elements:

• The article includes a photograph of a sculpture titled "The Scotish Thayer gravestein in Rural Cemetery on Grove Street." The sculpture is described as a large bronze figure of a volupteous woman in the nude, valued at $315,910.
• The sculpture is part of the Thayer Collection and is noted to be located in Rural Cemetery on Grove Street.
• A map or diagram is included at the bottom of the article, illustrating the Thayer Estate and its layout, showing the location of the Thayer grave, the Edgartown home, and other landmarks.

5. Additional Information:

• The article mentions that the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Fogg Art Museum have filed papers stating that "permanent exhibition" should be interpreted as consistent with the preservation of the works.
• The Worcester Probate Court is set to hear the case on Tuesday, and the judge will decide whether the art can remain with the museums or must be loaned under certain conditions.

Conclusion:

The image depicts a news article covering a significant legal case involving the estate of Martha Thayer, focusing on the disposition of a valuable art collection. The article provides detailed information about the collection's value, the legal dispute, and the potential beneficiaries, along with visual aids such as a photograph of a notable sculpture and a map of the Thayer Estate. The case highlights the complexities of art ownership and the role of museums in preserving and displaying such collections.