Archives Scrapbooks

Ctrl-C, Ctrl-V. Rinse, repeat.

Fogg Art Museum Scrapbooks, February 1978-October 1982

ARCH.2003.37, Rendition: 808841

Qwen, qwen.qwen3-vl-235b-a22b

This image displays a single page from the Independent, a newspaper or magazine, dated February 11, 1982, page 4. The page is dominated by a long-form investigative article titled:

“What happened to the Fogg Addition?”

By Charles Fishman


Visual Elements:

  • Top Illustration: A large, detailed black-and-white architectural sketch runs across the top third of the page. It depicts a proposed modern building addition (labeled with the caption “What the new Fogg building would have looked like.”) adjacent to an existing, classical-style institutional building (presumably the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University). The drawing includes trees, street-level figures, and surrounding buildings, giving a sense of scale and context.
  • Headline: The main headline is in a large, bold, serif font, centered below the illustration.
  • Sub-headline: Below the main headline, the article is subtitled “Abortion in Never-Never Land”, setting a critical and somewhat ironic tone.
  • Layout: The article is broken into several columns and sections with distinct sub-headings:
    • “Dollars and Sense” – Discusses budget overruns and financial mismanagement.
    • “Garage Sale at the Fogg” – Refers to proposed fundraising efforts, including selling parts of the collection.
  • Pull Quote / End Quote: A large, stylized quote box anchors the bottom of the page:

    “MATEP IS ALWAYS ON OUR MINDS, BUT THE SHADOW OF MATEP DID NOT FALL ON THE FOGG.”
    — HUGH CALKINS, CORPORATION MEMBER

  • Text Style: The body text is set in a traditional serif font, typical of newspapers of the era. The page shows some signs of age, such as yellowing paper and slight creases.

Content Summary (Based on Text):

The article is an exposé on the cancellation of a major planned $7.8 million addition to the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University.

  • The project was scrapped after the university discovered a $3 million funding shortfall.
  • Initial estimates of $5.6 million for construction ballooned to $7.8 million before being canceled; the article quotes Fogg Assistant Director Suzannah Fabing saying, “Stop! long before this point.”
  • The article uses terms like “abortion” (referencing the cancellation of the project) and “never-never land” to imply the project was unrealistic and poorly managed.
  • It details financial mismanagement, citing figures from Prof. Seymour Slive and Dean Henry Rosovsky, noting the university had already raised $14.5 million but needed $17 million total, leaving a $2.5 million gap.
  • It highlights internal conflict and blame-shifting, including a quote from Prof. Otis Grabar calling the project “an abortion... murder.”
  • The article suggests the university was in danger of “operating deficits” and even considers the sale of valuable art to fund a “stabilization fund” to cover the shortfall.
  • The concluding quote from Hugh Calkins (a Corporation Member) appears to be a veiled reference to the “Matep” (likely a code name or project) that wasn’t associated with the Fogg, possibly implying that other, perhaps more successful, projects were being prioritized.

Overall Tone:

The article is investigative, critical, and somewhat satirical. It portrays the failed expansion as a case study in bureaucratic mismanagement, academic hubris, and financial recklessness at a prestigious institution. The use of architectural illustration, dramatic headlines, and direct quotes aims to engage the reader and underscore the scale of the failed project.

Qwen, Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct

The image is a newspaper article titled "What happened to the Fogg Addition?" by Charles Fishman, published in the Independent on February 11, 1982. The article discusses the cancellation of the Fogg Art Museum's addition project at Harvard University, highlighting the financial challenges and the controversy surrounding the decision.

At the top of the article, there is a black and white sketch of what the new Fogg building was intended to look like. Below the title, the article is divided into several sections:

  1. "T" - This section features a quote from a Harvard University official expressing disbelief at the abrupt cancellation of the project.
  2. Abortion in Never-Never Land - This section delves into the financial and administrative issues leading to the cancellation.
  3. Dollars and Sense - This section explains the financial planning and budgeting for the project, detailing the cost overruns and the need for additional funding.
  4. Garage Sale at the Fogg - This section discusses the efforts to fundraise and the proposed sale of part of the Fogg's collection to create a "stabilization fund."

The article also includes a quote from Hugh Calkins, a corporation member, stating, "'MATEP IS ALWAYS ON OUR MINDS, BUT THE SHADOW OF MATEP DID NOT FALL ON THE FOGG.'"

The layout is typical of a newspaper article, with a mix of text and a sketch to convey the story visually.

Qwen, Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-72B-Instruct

This image is a page from a publication dated February 11, 1982, featuring an article titled "What happened to the Fogg Addition?" written by Charles Fishman. The article discusses the cancellation of plans for an addition to the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University.

At the top of the page, there is an illustration labeled "What the new Fogg building would have looked like," showing a modern architectural design integrated into the existing campus setting, including trees and other buildings.

The article is divided into sections with subheadings such as "Abortion in Never-Never Land," "Dollars and Sense," and "Garage Sale at the Fogg." It delves into the reasons for the cancellation, including financial constraints, budget overruns, and differing opinions within the university community about the project's viability and necessity. The text mentions specific individuals and their roles, such as Prof. Seymour Slive, Dean Henry Rosovsky, and Prof. Oleg Grabar, along with detailed financial figures related to the project's costs and fundraising efforts.

At the bottom of the page, there is a quote attributed to Hugh Calkins, a Corporation member, stating, "MATEP is always on our minds, but the shadow of MATEP did not fall on the Fogg." This quote is likely referencing concerns about financial management and the impact of the project on the university's overall budget.

Amazon, amazon.nova-pro-v1:0

The image is a page from a newspaper or magazine, featuring a combination of text and illustrations. The main headline reads, "What happened to the Fogg Addition?" and is accompanied by a subheading, "Abortion in Never-Never Land," which seems to be a metaphorical title rather than a literal one. The article is authored by Charles Fishman.

At the top of the page, there is a grayscale illustration of a building, presumably the Fogg Art Museum, with a proposed addition. The illustration shows a modern extension juxtaposed with the existing classical architecture, suggesting a contrast in architectural styles.

The text is divided into several sections. The first section, under the headline, begins with a quote from a Harvard University official, Prof. Seymour Slive, who comments on the cancellation of the Fogg Art Museum addition. He describes the abrupt cancellation as "Stop!" and emphasizes the importance of the project.

The article discusses the financial and administrative challenges that led to the cancellation of the Fogg Art Museum addition. It mentions that the project was $3.3 million short of the required $21.3 million and highlights the concerns about the impact on the existing Fogg building and its operating endowment.

The article also includes a sidebar with the title "Garage Sale at the Fogg," which humorously suggests that the university might have to sell off assets to cover the shortfall. This sidebar adds a light-hearted tone to the otherwise serious discussion of financial difficulties.

The page also features a smaller illustration of a man smoking a pipe, which might be a caricature or a symbolic representation related to the content of the article. The illustration is accompanied by a quote that suggests a sense of frustration or resignation about the situation.

The bottom of the page includes a quote from Hugh Calkins, a Corporation Member, who humorously comments on the situation, saying, "Matep is always on our minds, but the shadow of Matep did not fall on the Fogg." This quote adds a layer of irony to the narrative, possibly referencing a previous financial scandal or controversy at Harvard.

Overall, the page presents a detailed account of the challenges faced by Harvard University in funding and constructing the Fogg Art Museum addition, blending serious discussion with elements of humor and irony.

Amazon, amazon.nova-lite-v1:0

The image is a page from a newspaper with a title "What happened to the Fogg Addition?" The page contains a sketch of a building, probably the Fogg Art Museum. The text below the sketch reads "Abortion in Never-Never Land." The text on the page discusses the cancellation of the Fogg Art Museum addition and the reasons behind it. The article mentions that the project was canceled due to budget constraints and the need for renovation of the existing Fogg building.

Amazon, us.amazon.nova-2-lite-v1:0

The image is a scanned page from a publication titled "What happened to the Fogg Addition?" by Charles Fishman, published in The Independent on February 11, 1982. The page features a headline, subheading, and accompanying text, along with an illustration and a caption.

Key Elements of the Image:

1. Headline and Subheading:

  • Headline: "What happened to the Fogg Addition?"
  • Subheading: "Abortion in Never-Never Land"
  • Author: By Charles Fishman

2. Illustration:

  • Top Left: A detailed architectural drawing of a building labeled "What the new Fogg building would have looked like." The building appears to be a modern structure with a symmetrical design, featuring a central entrance, multiple windows, and a flat roof. The illustration is in black and white, giving it a schematic or blueprint-like appearance.

3. Main Text:

  • The article discusses the cancellation of the Fogg Art Museum's addition project at Harvard University. Key points include:
    • The project was canceled due to financial and logistical challenges.
    • The estimated cost of the addition was $16.5 million, but the actual construction and operating costs were significantly higher.
    • The university faced a $3.3 million shortfall, and the project was deemed financially unsustainable.
    • The article highlights the political and financial pressures surrounding the project, including concerns about budget deficits, inflation, and competing priorities.
    • Quotes from university officials, including Prof. Seymour Slive and Assistant Director Suzanna Fabry, are included, emphasizing the decision-making process and the reasons for cancellation.

4. Sidebar Text:

  • Dollars and Sense: A section summarizing the financial aspects of the project, including:
    • Initial estimates vs. actual costs.
    • The impact of inflation and rising construction costs.
    • The shortfall in funding and the decision to abandon the project.

5. Additional Text:

  • Garage Sale at the Fogg: A smaller section discussing the university's efforts to raise funds by selling surplus items, including a proposed "involuntary selling" of 53% of the Fogg's collection to cover deficits.
  • Quote at the Bottom: A poignant quote that reads:
    "MATEP IS ALWAYS ON OUR MINDS, BUT THE SHADOW OF MATEP DID NOT FALL ON THE FOGG."
    This quote is attributed to Hugh Calkins, a Corporation Member.

6. Layout and Design:

  • The page has a clean, newspaper-like layout with clear typography.
  • The illustration is placed above the main text, providing a visual representation of the proposed building.
  • The article is structured with headings, subheadings, and a sidebar, making it easy to follow.

Overall Context:

The image conveys a narrative about the cancellation of a significant architectural and cultural project at Harvard University. It highlights the financial, political, and logistical challenges that led to the project's abandonment, as well as the broader implications for the university's budget and priorities. The inclusion of quotes, financial data, and a visual representation of the proposed building adds depth and context to the story.

OpenAI, gpt-4o-2024-11-20

The image contains a newspaper page featuring an article titled "What happened to the Fogg Addition?" written by Charles Fishman. The top half of the page includes a black-and-white architectural sketch displaying what the proposed Fogg Addition building would have looked like. The building is depicted as a modern structure, contrasting with the existing architecture shown in the drawing.

Below the drawing, the article dives into a discussion about the cancellation of the planned addition to the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University, detailing financial challenges and other considerations that led to the decision. The page also contains subheadings such as "Abortion in Never-Never Land" and "Dollars and Sense," which provide further context to the story.

There is a quote set off from the article text near the bottom, attributed to Hugh Calkins, stating: "MATEP IS ALWAYS ON OUR MINDS, BUT THE SHADOW OF MATEP DID NOT FALL ON THE FOGG."

The article is dated February 11, 1982, and is from the publication "Independent," appearing on page 4. The layout includes a column of text discussing budgeting concerns, criticisms of the decision, and allocations of funds for the museum renovation versus the new addition.

OpenAI, gpt-4

The image shows a newspaper or magazine page featuring an article with the headline "What happened to the Fogg Addition?" written by Charles Fishman. The section is entitled "Abortion in Never-Never Land."

At the top of the page, above the headline, is a sketch of what the new Fogg building would have looked like. This sketch depicts a multi-story building with a modern architectural style situated beside an older classical-looking building with columns and pediments.

The article text discusses the situation surrounding the cancellation of an addition to the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University, mentioning financial aspects like fundraising and expenses, management decisions, and perhaps some controversy or issues that led to the project's halt.

Below the article is a bold statement in capital letters: "MATEP IS ALWAYS ON OUR MINDS, BUT THE SHADOW OF MATEP DID NOT FALL ON THE FOGG." followed by "Hugh Calkins CORPORATION MEMBER." This statement might be a separate note or commentary related to the main article, and Hugh Calkins is identified as a member of the corporation, presumably related to the discussed situation.

The date "February 11, 1982" is visible at the bottom of the page, indicating when the article was published.

OpenAI, gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14

The image is a scanned page from a newspaper or magazine called "INDEPENDENT" dated February 11, 1982. The page features an article titled "What happened to the Fogg Addition?" written by Charles Fishman. The subtitle of the article reads "Abortion in Never-Never Land."

At the top of the page, there is a black and white architectural sketch labeled "What the new Fogg building would have looked like." The sketch shows the proposed design for the Fogg Art Museum addition, depicting a multi-story building with a modern style, alongside some trees and an older building.

The article discusses the abrupt cancellation of the Fogg Art Museum's addition by Harvard University, addressing the financial and administrative reasons behind the decision. It mentions funding issues, budgeting problems, and the university's challenges in maintaining the project. Several officials and experts, including Seymour Slive and Prof. Oleg Grabar, are quoted offering their insights on the cancellation and its impact.

There is a section titled "Dollars and Sense" within the article, which provides details about the planned construction costs, funding shortfalls, and budget reallocations related to the project.

An additional smaller section titled "Garage Sale at the Fogg" talks about efforts to raise funds by selling part of the Fogg's collection.

At the bottom of the page, there is a large quotation attributed to Hugh Calkins, a corporation member, which reads: "'MATEP IS ALWAYS ON OUR MINDS, BUT THE SHADOW OF MATEP DID NOT FALL ON THE FOGG.'"

The overall theme is the financial and logistical challenges that led to the halting of the Fogg Art Museum addition project.

OpenAI, gpt-5-nano-2025-08-07

This is a scanned page from an old magazine/newspaper (dated February 11, 1982). The top features a black‑and‑white illustration with the caption “What the new Fogg building would have looked like.” The drawing shows a modern, rectangular addition on the left, connected to a more classical, columned building on the right, with trees and people in the foreground.

Below the illustration, a large headline asks: “What happened to the Fogg Addition?” and it is credited to By Charles Fishman. The page is divided into several small sections with subheads such as “Abortion in Never-Never Land,” “Dollars and Sense,” and “Garage Sale at the Fogg.” At the bottom there is a long quotation: “MATEP is always on our minds, but the shadow of MATEP did not fall on the Fogg,” attributed to Hugh Calkins. The overall layout is a multi-column article about the fate of the Fogg Addition.