Archives Scrapbooks

The image is a page from a book or document discussing the concept of dynamic symmetry and its influence on artists and archaeologists. The text mentions several key figures and theories related to this concept:

1. Dürer's System: The text describes how Albrecht Dürer attempted to learn from a dying artist and spent much of his life trying to work from this system. The system was supposed to produce perfect art but was never published and is now lost.

2. Arthur B. Davies: He was influenced by Gustav A. Eisen, a zoologist, who proposed the "life of inhalation" theory. This theory suggested that Greek art was based on the idea of inhalation, with figures depicted as inhaling rather than exhaling, which was supposed to raise the emotional tone of the art.

3. Gustav A. Eisen: He believed that the thorax, not the brain, is the center of emotional life and that Greek figures were depicted as inhaling. His theory was explained in a symposium publication called "The Greek Ideal."

4. Jay Hambidge: He popularized dynamic symmetry in the early 20th century, particularly through his book "Dynamic Symmetry in Composition." His work was influenced by the idea of the "life of inhalation" and the concept of the "deflected diagonal."

5. Controversy and Debate: The text mentions a debate around dynamic symmetry, with figures like Henri Focillon and Leon Kroll using the system, while others like Rhys Carpenter and G. M. A. Richter criticized it. Jay Hambidge defended dynamic symmetry and presented it as a mathematical system of composition.

6. Rose Arthur Pope: The text references her book "Dynamics of Painting," which discusses the coexistence of several elements in art, including academy, science, and patent medicine.

The page also includes an image of a drawing by George Bellows titled "Eleanor, Jean and Anna, 1920," which is an example of dynamic symmetry in composition. The drawing shows a group of people with geometric lines overlaid to illustrate the principles of dynamic symmetry.

Overall, the text discusses the historical context, key figures, and controversies surrounding the concept of dynamic symmetry in art.

The image is a page from a book or article discussing various theories related to art and composition, particularly focusing on dynamic symmetry.

Text Summary:

The text discusses several theories and their proponents:

1. Arthur B. Davies and the "Life of Inhalation" Theory:

   • Arthur B. Davies introduced modern art to the United States, linking it to a theory called the "life of inhalation," proposed by Gustav A. Eisen.
   • This theory suggests that Greek art was inspired by the act of inhaling, creating an emotional and spiritual effect.
   • Eisen argued that inhaling raises general emotional tones, and Davies used this to explain the emotional impact of his own art.

2. Eisen’s Extension and Hambidge’s Dynamic Symmetry:

   • Eisen extended his theory to include "life of inhalation" and "defected diagonal."
   • Jay Hambidge later proposed a more influential theory called "dynamic symmetry," which gained prominence in the 1920s.
   • This theory directed the attention of the art world toward new protest movements against accepted artistic practices.

3. Critique and Academic Views:

   • The text critiques these theories for lacking scientific evaluation and relegating dynamic symmetry to a practical tool rather than a critical one.
   • It mentions the coexistence of several elements in the theories, including science, pseudo-science, and a mix of academic and artistic practices.

Visual Elements:

• Photos:

  • The left side features two black-and-white images:
    • One of a man playing a cello.
    • Another of a woman holding a child, both in a staged composition.

• Diagram:

  • On the right side, there is a detailed diagram from Jay Hambidge's work on dynamic symmetry, showing geometric lines and shapes overlaid on artistic figures to demonstrate compositional principles.

References:

• The page references several key texts and figures:
  • George Bellows, Eleanor, Jean, and Anna in 1929.
  • Jay Hambidge’s "Dynamic Symmetry in Composition" (1923).
  • Arthur Pope’s teachings and writings, including "Introduction to the Language of Drawing and Painting" (1929).

Overall, the text delves into the historical context and impact of dynamic symmetry and other related theories on art and design, critiquing their scientific validity and practical application.

The image is a page from a book or an article discussing the historical and theoretical aspects of art, particularly focusing on the concept of dynamic symmetry.

Key points from the text include:

1. Maratta and Dürer:

   • Maratta and Dürer were aware of the principles of dynamic symmetry, with Maratta designing a Parthenon, a sphinx, and a pyramid that embodied these principles. Unfortunately, this work was never published and is now lost.

2. Arthur B. Davies and Gustav A. Eisen:

   • Arthur B. Davies was influenced by Gustav A. Eisen's theory of "life of inhalation," which was the basis of Eisen's book, The Great Chalice of Antich (1923). This theory suggests that the thorax, not the brain, is the center of emotional life and that Greek figures are depicted in a state of inhalation, raising the emotional tone of the artwork.
   • Davies experimented with the theory and used Eisen's chalk drawings to support his ideas.

3. Dynamic Symmetry:

   • Dynamic symmetry was a significant concept that influenced artists and architects, including George Bellows, Henri Matisse, and Leon Kroll.
   • Jay Hambidge proposed dynamic symmetry in 1903, with his work gaining prominence during the early 20th century.
   • Hambidge's theory was based on the diagonal and the "rectangle" or "squaring of the rectangle," which he believed was a mathematical system of composition of ancient origin.

4. Critiques and Evaluations:

   • Hambidge's theory was critiqued for its supposed occult power and its alignment with certain phenomena of plant growth.
   • Arthur Pope, who taught at Harvard, wrote about the art of the past being a concentrated study of a limited range of materials and terms, emphasizing that art should be based on broad eclecticism.
   • Hambidge's theory was seen as a mixture of academic, scientific, and patent medicine elements, indicating a blend of different disciplines.

5. References:

   • The text includes references to works by George Bellows, Jay Hambidge, and other notable figures in the art world, highlighting their contributions and critiques.

The page also contains an illustration by George Bellows, titled "Dynamic Symmetry in Composition," and a drawing from Jay Hambidge's work on dynamic symmetry.

The document discusses the historical context and influence of 'dynamic symmetry' in art, particularly in the early 20th century. It begins by mentioning the rediscovery of ancient principles by an individual named Maratta, who designed a heretofore unpublished system of proportions. This system was later explored by Arthur B. Davies, who connected it to the 'life of inhalation' theory of Gustav A. Eisen, a zoologist.

Eisen's theory, which suggested that inhalation was central to emotional life and artistic excellence, was promoted by Davies in his 'Great Chalice of Antioch' (1923). Davies and Eisen believed that understanding this theory would enhance artistic practice. The theory gained prominence in the 1920s, coinciding with a shift in design education due to the disruption of academic traditions by World War I.

The text highlights the use of dynamic symmetry by artists such as George Bellows, Jay Hambidge, and others, who applied mathematical principles to art composition. Hambidge, in particular, wrote extensively on the topic, and his work was influential. The document also notes the coexistence of various theories and practices, including academic knowledge, eclecticism, and a blend of science and art, which together influenced the development of modern art.

The document includes a reference to a book by George Bellows and mentions a drawing by Hambidge demonstrating dynamic symmetry. It concludes by summarizing the complex interplay between different theoretical approaches in the art world during this period.

The image is a page from a book, specifically page 101. The page contains a discussion on various theories related to art and design, particularly focusing on the concept of "dynamic symmetry."

Key points from the text include:

1. Dürer's Influence: The text mentions Albrecht Dürer, who supposedly knew ancient principles but did not publish them. It also references Maratta's design of a Parthenon, a sphinx, and a pyramid, which were considered more perfect than any other heretofore known.

2. Arthur B. Davies and the Armory Show: Davies introduced modern art at the Armory Show, with a theory about the "life of inhalation" in art, which he claimed was the basis for excellence in Greek art. This theory was detailed in his book, The Great Chalice of Antichio (1923).

3. Gustav A. Eisen: Eisen's ideas about the brain and the thorax were central to Davies' theory, suggesting that emotional life and art are linked through inhalation and exhalation.

4. Jay Hambidge and Dynamic Symmetry: Hambidge's theory of dynamic symmetry was influential, especially during the early 1920s. Hambidge believed it was a mathematical system of composition with roots in ancient Greek art. He presented his ideas through various publications and lectures, including his work on the diagonal and occult power in compositions.

5. Reactions and Acceptance: The text discusses various reactions to Hambidge’s ideas, including criticism from figures like George Bellows, Henri and Leon Kroll, and Denman Ross, and support from others like L. D. Casky and G. M. A. Richter.

6. Hambidge’s Theories: Hambidge’s theories combined elements of aesthetics, science, and academic study, blending classical and modern influences to create a comprehensive approach to art composition.

The bottom of the page includes an illustration of a drawing by Jay Hambidge titled "Dynamic Symmetry in Composition," showcasing the kind of complex, symmetrical designs Hambidge was discussing.

The image shows a page from a book or a printed document. The text discusses various art theories and their influences, focusing on dynamic symmetry and its impact on artists and architects. Key figures mentioned include Jay Hambidge, Arthur B. Davies, Gustav A. Eisen, and others. The text also references specific artworks and the historical context, such as the Armory Show and the reactions against academic tradition in the early 20th century. Additionally, there is an illustration at the bottom of the page, which appears to be a drawing related to dynamic symmetry. The page number at the bottom right corner is 101.

This image shows a printed page from a book or article, which is focused on the topics of art, symmetry, and possibly art theory, as inferred from the visible text. The left side of the page includes a historical black and white photograph of a person in a dress, seated and engaging with a visual task. The photograph is accompanied by a caption that reads "George Bellows, ELEANOR, JEAN AND ANNA, 1920, oil, 55 9/16 x 66", Albright Art Gallery," which indicates that the photograph is documenting a painting by George Bellows. Below this photograph, there's a print identifier "1948."

The right portion of the page features an illustration with multiple lines intersecting and forming various geometric shapes over two figures, suggestive of an analysis of compositional elements based on dynamic symmetry. The text around the illustration discusses various aspects of dynamic symmetry, art theory, and their application. There are references to academic figures and publications, indicating a scholarly discussion on the subject. The bottom of the page has "PAGE 101" indicating that this is a page from a larger work.

The image shows a page from a book or magazine discussing "Dynamic Symmetry" and its influence on art and archeology. The text explores the concepts behind this theory, mentioning key figures such as Arthur B. Davies, Gustav A. Eisen, Henri and Leon Kroll, L. D. Caskey, and Jay Hambidge. It also references the relationship between dynamic symmetry, Greek art, and the emotional and spiritual aspects of drawing.

At the bottom of the page, there are two images side-by-side. The left image is a black-and-white photograph titled "George Bellows, ELEANOR, JEAN AND ANNA, 1920, oil, 59 x 66", Albright Art Gallery," showing four people sitting and one standing, although the faces are blurred for privacy. The right image is a line drawing labeled "Bellows's drawing, from Jay Hambidge, Dynamic Symmetry in Composition... 1923," which shows the same group of people in a schematic composition with geometric lines illustrating the principles of dynamic symmetry.

The text also discusses the tensions between the scientific approach to art, the role of academic traditions, and the attempts to rejuvenate art through a mix of scientific, academic, and almost mystical elements. The page number, 101, is noted at the bottom right corner.

The image appears to be a page from an academic or historical publication. The page contains text and images. The text is divided into two main sections. The left section discusses the influence of dynamic symmetry on artists and architects, citing examples such as Henri Bellows and Leon Kroll. It also mentions the work of Arthur Davies and Gustav A. Eisen, who explored the concept of "life of inhalation" and its connection to ancient Greek art and architecture.

The right section of the text continues the discussion of dynamic symmetry, focusing on its application in various fields, including science and patent medicine. It highlights the tendency to equate art with science and the desire to create immutable laws in art.

The image on the left side of the page shows a family portrait with a man, a woman, and a child. The image on the right side depicts a diagram illustrating the principles of dynamic symmetry, with lines and geometric shapes.

Overall, the image provides an overview of the concept of dynamic symmetry and its impact on various disciplines, with a focus on art, architecture, and science.

The image is a scanned page from a book or magazine that discusses the concept of "dynamic symmetry" in art and architecture, with a focus on its proponents and critics during the early 20th century. The text mentions several figures associated with dynamic symmetry, including Dürer, Arthur B. Davies, Gustav A. Eisen, and Jay Hambidge. It also references Leon Kroll, Fine D. Casky, G. M. A. Richter, and Edwin M. Blake as individuals who either supported or opposed the theory. The page includes a black-and-white photograph of George Bellows' painting "Eleanor, Jean and Anna," along with a diagram illustrating the principles of dynamic symmetry. The image appears to be from a publication that explores the intersection of art, science, and mathematics in the context of modern art movements.