Archives Scrapbooks

The image appears to be a page from a publication, specifically a book critique section. The page is titled "BOOK CRITIQUES" and contains two separate critiques, one on "Agnolo Bronzino" by Arthur McComb and another on "Attic Black-Figure: a Sketch" by J.D. Beazley.

• Top Critique: "Agnolo Bronzino":

  • The critique discusses the book "Agnolo Bronzino" by Arthur McComb, published by Harvard University Press in 1928. The book is described as occupying a secure place among the academic masters of the cinquecento in Florence, with a detailed analysis of Bronzino's work, including his portraits, allegorical bas-reliefs, and his transition from the influence of Pontormo and Michelangelo to his own style.
  • The reviewer praises the author's work, noting the inclusion of catalogs of authentic paintings and attributed works, as well as drawings and tapestries based on Bronzino's designs. The book is commended for its valuable series of sixty-one plates, including authentic Bronzinos and attributed works for comparison.
  • The reviewer expresses regret over the lack of inclusion of certain works in the plates, such as the Bronze Serpent fresco of the Cappella Eleonora, Palazzo Vecchio, Florence, and the Stroganoff Holy Family.
  • The reviewer, William Sener Rusk, concludes with a quote from Emerson and a positive note about the book's value, especially for those studying the Uffizi portraits and the London Allegory.

• Bottom Critique: "Attic Black-Figure: a Sketch":

  • The critique discusses the book "Attic Black-Figure: a Sketch" by J.D. Beazley, published by Humphrey Milford, London, in 1929. The book is described as a sketch that gives an interpretation of the black-figure style of Attic vase-painting in its decorative function, outlining its history, and appreciating its great masters.
  • The reviewer, H.R.W. Smith, commends Beazley's pathfinding connoisseurship and the excellent plates reproducing twenty-six vases. The reviewer notes that workers in the ill-mapped field of black-figure painting will rejoice at Beazley's contributions and that a wider circle will enjoy this study as a masterpiece of sure and subtle criticism.

The page has a title header "Art + Archaeology" with a date of "June 1930," indicating the publication in which these critiques appear.

This image is a scanned page from a publication titled "BOOK CRITIQUES," dated June 1930, related to the field of art and archaeology. The page appears to be aged with a yellowish tint and includes three hole punches on the left side, likely for filing purposes.

The top of the page has handwritten text that reads "Art & Archaeology" and "June 1930."

The main content consists of a critique of the book "Agnolo Bronzino" by Arthur McComb. The critique discusses Bronzino's place in the history of art, his style, and the contents of the book, which includes a detailed study of his works. It mentions the book's structure, the inclusion of various catalogues, and the quality of the plates.

The critique is signed by William Seher Rusk.

Below this critique, there is another critique of a book titled "Attic Black-Figure: a Sketch" by J. D. Beazley. This critique discusses the book's content, which interprets the black-figured style of Attic vase-painting, its history, and its great masters. It also mentions the book's appendices and plates.

The critique of Beazley's book is signed by H. R. W. Smith.

The page is well-organized, with clear headings and structured paragraphs, making it easy to read and follow the content.

This image shows a single, aged, off-white sheet of paper that has been hole-punched on its left edge, suggesting it was part of a bound or filed document. The paper is slightly curled and shows some discoloration, indicating its age.

At the top center of the page is the title “BOOK CRITIQUES” in bold, uppercase letters.

In the upper right corner, there is a handwritten note in black ink that reads:
“Art & Archaeology
June 1930”
This suggests the page is either from or intended for the June 1930 issue of the journal “Art & Archaeology.”

The page contains two distinct book reviews:

1. Review of “Agnolo Bronzino” by Arthur McComb

• Publication details: Pp. xx, 173; 61 Plates. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass. 1928. $7.50.
• The review, written by William Sener Rusk, is a detailed critical analysis of McComb’s monograph on the 16th-century Florentine painter Agnolo Bronzino.
• It praises McComb for compiling a comprehensive catalog of authentic paintings and attributions, noting his clarity and balanced approach to complex attribution issues.
• The review highlights that while many attributions are new (e.g., the Stibbert Museum’s portrait-bust of Francesco I), they are not always certain.
• Criticisms include regret over the exclusion of the "Bronze Serpent" fresco from the plates and minor inaccuracies in the text (e.g., referring to a “figure with the pitcher”).
• The reviewer defends Bronzino’s academic style against accusations of coldness, noting his later lyricism and mastery of form.

2. Review of “Attic Black-Figure: a Sketch” by J. D. Beazley

• Publication details: From the Proceedings of the British Academy, Vol. xiv. Pp. 50; 16 plates; paper binding, Humphrey Milford, London. 1929. $2.50.
• This review, by H. R. W. Smith, describes Beazley’s lecture as an insightful interpretation of Attic vase-painting in its decorative function.
• It notes Beazley’s “path-finding connoisseurship” and positions the work as a master-piece of “sure and subtle criticism,” appealing to a wider audience beyond specialists.
• The review mentions appendices listing attributions and excellent plates reproducing twenty-six vases.

Overall, the image depicts a scholarly page from an early 20th-century journal or archive, focused on art historical criticism. The content reflects the academic tone and concerns of art scholarship in the 1920s and early 1930s, with attention to attribution, stylistic analysis, and the scholarly reception of new monographs and lectures.

The image shows a page from a book with a title "Antiquary Archaeology" at the top. Below the title, there is a handwritten date "June 1930" in the center of the page. The page contains two book critiques. The first critique is about "Agnolo Bronzino" by Arthur McComb. The critique mentions that Bronzino occupies a secure place among academic masters of the cinquecento in Florence and discusses his portrait busts and illustrations. The second critique is about "Black Figures Sketch" by J. D. Beatley. The critique talks about an interpretation of the black-figured style of Attic vase-painting and mentions that it is not recognized before the Lysippides and Achelous painters. The critiques are written in a formal tone and provide insights into the works of the artists.

The image depicts a page from a book, specifically a section titled "BOOK CRITIQUES." The page is from June 1930 and contains a review of a book titled "Agnolo Bronzino" by Arthur McComb, published by Harvard University Press. The review is written by an anonymous author.

The review begins by praising Agnolo Bronzino's secure place among the academic masters of the cinquecento in Florence. It notes that Bronzino's early works were influenced by Pontormo and a preoccupation with Michelangelo's poses, but his later works, particularly his portraits, illustrate the value of academic training in a traditional period. The reviewer mentions that Bronzino's tactility in abstract designs is evident in his works, and he even recalls Ingres and Holbein in certain aspects.

The reviewer commends Arthur McComb for compiling a monograph that satisfactorily fulfills the purpose of such works. Following the introductory pages, the book includes forty appreciation pages, a series of catalogs, and catalogs of attributed and school pieces and of paintings attributed to and pictures and tapestries on Bronzino's lost pictures. The book concludes with a valuable series of sixty plates, including not only authentic Bronzino works but also a number of attributed and school works for comparison.

The reviewer also mentions that McComb summarizes the pros and cons in each case with admirable clarity and usually reaches a decision, wisely leaving detailed discussion to the appended bibliographies. Some of his attributions are new, such as the "Sibille" in the Galleria Sabauda of Turin, which is attributed to Bronzino. The reviewer notes that the catalog raisonné of attributed works is not always clear, especially in cases where other specialists have the weight of expert opinion.

The reviewer highlights that the most satisfactory distance from which one can expect to gain personal insight into Bronzino's works is by way of personal opinion. The reviewer also mentions that the book includes a valuable series of sixty plates, including not only authentic Bronzino works but also a number of attributed and school works for comparison.

The review concludes with a mention of another book, "Attic Black-Figure Sketch" by J. D. Beazley, which is described as an interpretation of the black-figured style of Attic vase-painting in its decorative function. The reviewer notes that Professor Beazley's study is a valuable contribution to the field of black-figure vase painting and will be enjoyed by both specialists and general readers.

The image depicts a page from a book or publication titled "BOOK CRITIQUES". The page appears to be from a scholarly or academic review section, discussing various works of art and literature. The content is formatted in a structured, typographic style typical of academic journals or art criticism publications.

Key Observations:

1. Title and Header:

   • The page is titled "BOOK CRITIQUES", indicating that it contains reviews or critiques of books.
   • At the top right, there is a handwritten note: "Art & Archaeology June 1930", suggesting the publication date and subject matter.

2. Content Layout:

   • The page is divided into several sections, each reviewing different books or works.
   • The text is dense and formatted in a columned layout, typical of academic journals.

3. Reviewed Works:

   • The first review is titled "Agno Bronzino. By Arthur McComb. Pp. xx, 173. 61 Plates. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass. 1928. $7.50."

     • This review discusses a monograph on the artist Agnolo Bronzino, authored by Arthur McComb. The review highlights the book's value as a reference work, its comprehensive catalog of Bronzino's works, and its contributions to understanding the artist's place in the Renaissance and Baroque periods.
     • The reviewer, H. R. W. Smith, praises the clarity of McComb's writing and the book's detailed bibliography but notes some challenges in attributing certain works.

   • The second review is titled "Attic Black-Figured: A Sketch. By J. D. Beazley. Annual Lecture on the Aspects of Art, Henriette Hertz Trust of the British Academy, 1928. Vol. xxx. Pp. 50; 10 plates; paper binding. Humphrey Milford, London. 1929. $2.50."

     • This review discusses a lecture by J. D. Beazley on Attic black-figure painting. The reviewer appreciates Beazley's expertise and the lecture's value as a concise overview of the subject, though they suggest it may be more suited for specialists due to its specialized focus.

4. Typography and Formatting:

   • The text is printed in a serif font, consistent with academic publications of the early 20th century.
   • Subheadings, such as the titles of the books being reviewed, are bolded or emphasized for clarity.
   • The page includes page numbers, citations, and references, indicating a scholarly tone.

5. Handwritten Note:

   • In the top right corner, there is a handwritten note: "Art & Archaeology June 1930", which likely indicates the issue or volume of the publication.

Overall Impression:

The page is a well-organized and scholarly critique of two books, reflecting the academic and artistic discourse of the early 20th century. It combines detailed analysis, critical evaluation, and references to other works, making it a valuable resource for readers interested in art history and criticism. The inclusion of both a monograph on a Renaissance artist and a lecture on ancient Greek art suggests a broad scope of interest in art history across different periods.

The image depicts a page from a book critique, featuring a beige background with black text. The page is divided into two columns, each containing a critique of a book. The title "BOOK CRITIQUES" is prominently displayed at the top of the page, followed by the name of the book being critiqued and the author's name. The critique itself is written in a formal, academic tone, providing an in-depth analysis of the book's content, style, and themes.

The page also includes a handwritten note in the top-right corner, which appears to be a signature or initials. The overall design of the page suggests that it is part of a larger publication, such as a literary journal or academic anthology. The use of a beige background and black text creates a clean and professional appearance, while the critique itself provides valuable insights into the book's merits and limitations.

The image depicts a page from an academic journal or publication, featuring a book review titled "Book Critiques." The page is yellowed and has two holes punched along its left edge, suggesting it was once part of a binder or folder. The text is written in black ink and appears to be a typed article.

At the top of the page, a handwritten note reads "Art + Archaeology June 1930," indicating the publication date. Below this, the title "BOOK CRITIQUES" is centered in bold font, followed by the name of the reviewer, Arthur McComb, and the title of the book being reviewed, "Agnolo Bronzino."

The review itself is a detailed analysis of the book, discussing its content, style, and significance. The reviewer provides a thorough evaluation of the book's strengths and weaknesses, offering insights into the author's approach and methodology.

Overall, the image presents a snapshot of academic discourse in the early 20th century, showcasing the critical thinking and analytical skills required of scholars in the field of art history.

The image depicts a yellowed, aged page featuring a book review titled "Book Critiques." The page is divided into two columns, each containing a distinct review. The left column reviews "Agnolo Bronzino" by Arthur McComb, while the right column reviews "Attic Black-Figure: A Sketch" by J.D. Beazley. The page is bound with three holes on the left side, indicating that it was once part of a larger document or binder. A handwritten notation at the top of the page reads "Art & Archaeology" and "June 1930," suggesting that the page is a clipping from a journal or magazine published during that time period. The background of the image is a plain gray color, providing a neutral backdrop for the aged page.

The image presents a scanned or photographed page from an academic journal, featuring a book review titled "BOOK CRITIQUES" in bold, black text at the top. The page is yellowed and has three holes punched along its left side, suggesting it was once part of a binder.

Header Section:

• The title "BOOK CRITIQUES" is prominently displayed in bold, black text.
• Handwritten notes in black ink are visible above the title, reading "Dept. of Archaeology June 1980."

Content:

• The page contains two book reviews, each discussing a different publication:
  • The first review is titled "Agnolo Bronzino. By Arthur McComb." and provides an analysis of the book.
  • The second review is titled "Attic Black-Figure: A Sketch. By J.D. Beazley" and offers a critique of the book.

Footer Section:

• The author's name, "H.R.W. SMITH," is printed at the bottom of the page.

Background:

• The background of the image is a light gray color, providing a neutral backdrop for the scanned page.

Overall, the image appears to be a scanned or photographed page from an academic journal, featuring book reviews and handwritten notes.