Archives Scrapbooks

The image is a photograph of a newspaper article from The New York Times, dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The headline of the article is "Clashing Views Reshape Art History," and it is written by Grace Glueck.

The article discusses a revisionist movement in the field of art history, which challenges traditional views and interpretations of visual arts. It mentions that this movement is led by a younger generation of scholars who are questioning established norms and introducing new perspectives. The article highlights how these scholars are re-evaluating the works of famous artists and reinterpreting them in light of contemporary issues such as social, political, and economic contexts.

A significant portion of the article focuses on the painting "A Bar at the Folies-Bergère" by Édouard Manet, which is currently on display at the Fogg Art Museum. The article presents two contrasting views on the painting. One view, by Anne Coffin Hanson, emphasizes the painting's sensuous textures and tangible reality. The other view, by T.J. Clark, discusses the painting's commercial and social context, suggesting that the barmaid in the painting is depicted as an object of desire to attract customers.

The article also mentions the influence of feminist and Marxist theories on this revisionist movement, noting that these theories have led to a more critical and contextual analysis of art. The overall tone of the article suggests that these new interpretations are causing a significant shift in the way art history is understood and taught.

The photograph of the newspaper article is placed inside a book or a folder, with the edges of the book visible around the newspaper clipping.

The image shows a page from a newspaper, specifically from The New York Times, dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The article is titled "Clashing Views Reshape Art History."

The article discusses the impact of revisionist historians in the field of art history. The term "revisionists" is used to describe scholars challenging traditional narratives and perspectives on art. The article highlights how these revisionists are re-evaluating historical artworks and their contexts, focusing more on the social, political, and cultural aspects rather than just the aesthetic elements.

Key points from the article include:

1. The use of methodologies such as psychoanalysis, anthropology, and linguistics to re-examine art history.
2. A focus on the social and political contexts of art, including the role of the artist in relation to class and society.
3. The example of Édouard Manet's "Bar at the Folles Bergère," which is discussed from two contrasting perspectives:
   • One view emphasizes Manet's modern sensibilities and his attempt to preserve the tangible reality of the scene.
   • The other view considers it as a detached, commercial object viewed through the lens of a customer's perspective.

The article also mentions specific artworks and scholars like J. Clark, who is noted for his book "The Painting of Modern Life," which introduces a new approach to understanding the historical context of artworks.

It notes the impact of these revisionist approaches on museums and academic institutions, influencing how art is interpreted and displayed. The article suggests that these new interpretations are reshaping the understanding of art history and its relationship with contemporary society.

The image shows a page from The New York Times, dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The headline of the article is "Clashing Views Reshape Art History," written by Grace Glueck. The article discusses a movement of scholars who are challenging traditional art history, questioning its methods and expanding its scope to include social, political, and cultural contexts. The scholars, labeled as "revisionists," argue for a more holistic approach to art history, incorporating insights from other disciplines like sociology, anthropology, and linguistics.

The article features a prominent illustration or photograph of a person, possibly related to the new perspectives being discussed. The text also mentions specific figures and institutions, such as T.J. Clark, author of "The Painting of Modern Life," and the Frick Art Museum, where these new viewpoints are being taught and debated. The article suggests that these revisionist views are being integrated into academic programs, affecting how a new generation of scholars and professionals in the art world perceive and study art history.

The image is a newspaper clipping from The New York Times, dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The article, titled "Clashing Views Reshape Art History," is written by Grace Glueck. It discusses how contemporary perspectives and interdisciplinary approaches are challenging and transforming traditional views of art history.

Key Points of the Article:

1. Challenging Traditional Views:

   • Some scholars are re-evaluating the established narratives of art history, which have often been Eurocentric and male-dominated.
   • This rethinking involves integrating new methodologies from other academic disciplines, such as psychology, anthropology, and social history.

2. Revising Historical Structures:

   • The article mentions that the traditional framework of art history, which has been primarily focused on Western art, is being questioned.
   • Scholars are exploring art from different cultures and time periods, bringing a broader and more inclusive perspective.

3. Interdisciplinary Approaches:

   • Historians and critics are incorporating insights from various fields to understand the context and impact of artworks.
   • This includes looking at the sociopolitical climate, gender issues, and the influence of non-Western cultures.

4. Example of Manet’s 'Bar at the Folies Bergère':

   • The article presents two contrasting views on Édouard Manet's painting, "A Bar at the Folies Bergère."
   • Anne Coffin Hanson views the painting as preserving the sensuous textures, emphasizing its tangible reality.
   • T.J. Clark argues that the painting reflects a more complex, detached social commentary, focusing on the barmaid's alienated experience and the economic context of the era.

5. Impact on Education and Museums:

   • The changes in art historical perspectives are influencing educational programs and museum exhibitions.
   • Institutions such as the Courtauld Institute and Harvard University are noted for revising their approaches to incorporate these new ideas.

The article overall highlights a significant shift in art history, driven by new scholarly approaches and an expanded understanding of cultural and historical contexts.

The image shows a page from The New York Times, dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The headline of the article is "Clashing Views Reshape Art History," written by Grace Glueck.

The article discusses a group of scholars known as "revisionists" who are challenging traditional methods of studying art history. These revisionists are described as a "boisterous and often contentious" community that includes professors and students from various universities. They are characterized by their unconventional approaches to art history, incorporating disciplines like psychoanalysis, anthropology, and linguistics.

The article highlights that these revisionists focus on the cultural context and ideological elements of art, rather than just the aesthetic qualities. For example, it mentions a book by J. Clark that interprets Manet's painting "Olympia" by considering the context of prostitution and the artist's views on society.

The revisionists' approach is also influencing museums, such as the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard, where they advocate for a more "intellectual" approach over a purely aesthetic one. The article notes that these new perspectives are reshaping the tastes of a new generation of curators, collectors, and critics.

Additionally, the article touches on the controversy and resistance from more traditional art historians, who see these new methods as a threat to established academic practices. The article concludes by indicating that this debate is ongoing, with both sides presenting their arguments through teaching, writing, and lectures.

The image shows a newspaper clipping from The New York Times, dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The article is titled "Clashing Views Reshape Art History" and is written by Grace Glueck.

The article discusses the impact of a group of scholars, often referred to as "revisionists," who are challenging traditional art historical narratives. These revisionists are described as challenging the structuralism and formalism that have dominated art history, instead focusing on issues such as class, race, gender, and the politics of art.

The article highlights the debates around the interpretation of artworks, particularly referencing Manet's "Bar at the Folies Bergère," with differing views on how the work should be understood. One perspective emphasizes Manet's detached portrayal, while another suggests a more nuanced, potentially critical, reading of the painting.

The article also mentions the influence of these new approaches in educational institutions, such as Harvard, where the museum training program has been revamped to incorporate these ideas. It notes the impact on museums, including the Fogg Art Museum, which has shifted its focus from purely aesthetic issues to broader social and political contexts.

The clipping includes a black-and-white image of Édouard Manet, which accompanies the discussion about his work. The text continues on the next page, indicated by a "Continued on Page 22" notice.

The image shows a newspaper article from "The New York Times" dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The title of the article is "Clashing Views Reshape Art History," and although the author's byline is partially obscured, it appears to be written by someone with the last name Glueck. There are two columns of text visible, with excerpts providing different perspectives on art history. One side highlights a quote relating to Manet's "Bar at the Folies-Bergère," attributing comments to Anne Coffin Hanson and Timothy J. Clark, which seem to offer contrasting interpretations of the art piece. The article discusses the evolving nature of art criticism and historical perspectives. In the background, the newspaper is laid open on a light tan surface with a red book spine visible along the left edge, suggesting it might be resting on top of a book or a notebook.

The image shows an open book displaying a page from The New York Times dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The headline of the article is "Clashing Views Reshape Art History", authored by Grace Glueck. The article discusses the impact of revisionist perspectives on art history, highlighting how new interpretations and debates are reshaping traditional narratives.

Key Elements in the Image:

1. Headline and Subheading:

   • The headline, "Clashing Views Reshape Art History", indicates the central theme of the article: the evolving and contested nature of art history due to new critical approaches.
   • The byline credits Grace Glueck as the author.

2. Visual Content:

   • On the right side of the page, there is a black-and-white illustration of a person, likely an artist or a figure related to the discussion of art. The illustration is accompanied by a caption that reads:

     "Manet's 'Bar at the Folies Bergère' has done: 'What Manet has done is to rearrange a momentary view... preserving the sensuous textures which give the picture its tangible reality.'"
     - The quote is attributed to Anne Coffin Hanson, with a reference to "Édouard Manet: Catalogue Raisonné 1832–1883."

   • Below this, another caption states:

     "She is detached... that is the best description. The customer textures which she one evidently thinks which money can buy."
     - This quote is attributed to Timothy J. Clark.

3. Text Content:

   • The article begins with a quote: "SOME CALL THEM 'RADICALS.' REVISIONISTS, THEY ARE SIMPLY TROUBLEMAKERS." This sets the tone for the discussion about how revisionist thinkers are challenging established narratives in art history.
   • The text elaborates on how these revisionists draw from diverse fields such as structuralism, feminism, Marxism, and postcolonial theory to reinterpret art history. It mentions specific examples, such as the work of John Clark on Manet’s A Bar at the Folies Bergère, and how these reinterpretations challenge traditional views.
   • The article also references institutions like the Fogg Art Museum and the Orsay Museum, noting how these institutions are embracing new approaches to art history.

4. Layout and Design:

   • The page is formatted in a classic newspaper style, with a clear hierarchy of text and visuals.
   • The left side contains the main body of the article, while the right side features the illustration and accompanying quotes, creating a balanced visual composition.
   • The page appears to be part of a larger collection or archive, as suggested by the visible spine of the book and the slightly worn edges of the pages.

Contextual Insights:

• The article reflects a period in the late 1980s when art history was undergoing significant transformation due to the influence of postmodern and critical theory. Scholars were re-examining canonical works and artists through new lenses, challenging traditional narratives and hierarchies.
• The inclusion of quotes from art historians like Anne Coffin Hanson and Timothy J. Clark underscores the scholarly debate surrounding these revisionist approaches.

Overall, the image captures a moment in art history where traditional interpretations were being questioned and redefined, highlighting the dynamic and evolving nature of the discipline.

A newspaper is open to the page of an article titled "Clashing Views Reshape Art History." The page has a red border, and the newspaper is folded in half. The article is about a debate among art historians about how to approach art history. The article features a black and white portrait of a woman. The woman has short hair and is looking at the camera.

This image shows a page from "The New York Times" dated Sunday, December 20, 1987. The page features an article titled "Clashing Views Reshape Art History." The article discusses how revisionist views are challenging traditional art history, emphasizing new perspectives such as feminism, Marxism, psychoanalysis, and the social and political contexts of art. The page includes a black-and-white photograph of a woman's portrait, possibly related to the discussion of art history and its reinterpretation. The article is accompanied by a quote from Anne Coffin Hanson, an art historian, and a catalog essay by Edouard Manet. The page also references the influence of artists like Manet and the changing roles of curators and art historians.