Archives Scrapbooks

The image shows a page from a scrapbook or an album containing several newspaper clippings. The page is titled "Crimson, 63-64," suggesting it may be related to Harvard University, as "Crimson" is often associated with Harvard.

Here is a detailed summary of each clipping:

1. Top Left Clipping: "SEE HARVARD MURAL AS SLAP AT GERMANY"

   • This article discusses a mural by John Singer Sargent in the entrance foyer of the Germanic Museum at Harvard. The mural, titled "The Triumph of Religion," has been interpreted as a critique of German militarism. The article notes that the mural has been moved to a less prominent location due to controversy.

2. Top Center Clipping: "MURAL CAUSES TROUBLE IN GERMANIC MUSEUM"

   • This article reports on a controversy surrounding two murals in the Germanic Museum. The first mural, "The Twilight of the Norse Gods," was criticized for its depiction of Nazi Germany. The second mural, "The Ring of the Nibelungen," was also controversial for its portrayal of military themes and the inclusion of a figure resembling a German soldier.

3. Top Right Clipping: "New Germanic Museum Mural Causes Controversies Again"

   • This article discusses the ongoing controversy over a mural in the Germanic Museum. The mural, which depicts modern Germany, has been criticized for its portrayal of the Church and labor. The artist, John Singer Sargent, defended his work, stating that it was meant to be a gift from Mrs. Martin Lowe of New York.

The clippings collectively highlight the controversies and interpretations surrounding the murals in the Germanic Museum at Harvard, particularly focusing on their perceived critiques of German militarism and societal issues.

The image shows an open book containing newspaper clippings about a controversial mural in a German museum. The clippings are dated around 1934 and 1935, based on the handwritten dates and the style of the articles.

The main article on the left page is titled "See Harvard Mural as Slap at Germany: War Techniques in Second Rubenstein Painting." It describes how a mural by an American artist, Rubenstein, was found in the German Museum of Fine Arts in Dresden. The mural depicted a group of men in military attire, including gas masks, which were perceived as a slap against Germany. The article mentions that the first mural portrayed a Nordic figure with a group of men wearing military uniforms, and the second mural depicted a Nordic figure with a group of men in gas masks, representing a defiant Nordic type. The article also mentions that the murals were seen as rebukes to Nazi Germany and were criticized for their depiction of Nordic figures and their association with militarism.

The clippings on the right page are titled "Mural Causes Trouble in German Museum" and "New German Museum Mural Causes Controversies Again." These articles detail the controversy surrounding the murals, with one depicting "The Twilight of the Gods" and the other "The Ring of the Nibelungen." The articles describe how the murals were seen as rebukes to Nazi Germany, with one depicting knights of the Crusades and another showing a group of men in military attire. The articles mention the involvement of a director named Charles L. Kuhn and the removal of the murals, possibly due to their perceived negative implications for Nazi propaganda.

The handwritten dates in the upper left corner (August 14) and upper right corner (August 14) suggest these articles were collected or marked for reference on that date.

The image shows a page from a newspaper clipping dated October 14, 1941, focusing on the controversies surrounding two murals at Harvard’s German Museum. The article is split into two main sections.

1. Left Side:

   • The headline reads: "See Harvard Mural as Slap at Germany."
   • The article discusses the completion of the second mural in the German Museum at Harvard University, which depicts war techniques in Nazi Germany.
   • The first mural, "The Ring of the Nibelungen," was painted last year and caused controversy due to its depiction of the German military. It was criticized for portraying a Norse figure with a helmet and carrying a spear, which some interpreted as a symbol of Nazism.
   • The second mural, "The Twilight of the Gods," is said to have been influenced by Nazi ideology and was painted by W. Rubenstein, who had ties to the Nazi regime. It is seen as a depiction of Germanic warriors and is alleged to be a slap at Germany.

2. Right Side:

   • The headlines here are "Mural Causes Trouble in German Museum" and "New German Museum Mural Causes Controversies Again."
   • It elaborates on the second mural's depiction, which includes images of knights, crusaders, and other historical figures, leading to debates about its representation and historical accuracy.
   • The text mentions that some individuals argue that the mural is a misrepresentation of historical German military figures and that it should not be perceived as a modern depiction of Nazi Germany.
   • It highlights the different viewpoints: one group argues for the mural's historical accuracy, while another defends it against accusations of promoting Nazi ideology.

Overall, the article captures the heated debate around these murals, which have sparked significant controversy regarding their portrayal and the historical context they represent.

The image shows an open book with two newspaper clippings pasted on one of the pages. The book appears to be a scrapbook, and the page is dated "August, 1934" at the top.

First Clipping (on the left side):

• Title: "SEE HARVARD MURAL AS SLAP AT GERMANY"
• Subtitle: "War Techniques in Second Rubenstein Painting"
• Content Summary: The clipping discusses a mural at Harvard University that is perceived as a critique of German war techniques. The mural, created by an artist named Rubenstein, is the second in a series. It features a scene from the Thirty Years' War, depicting soldiers in various poses. The first mural, "The Ring of the Nibelungen," was said to be a tribute to the spirit of the Middle Ages. The second mural is seen as controversial, with some believing it to be a direct response to the current political climate in Germany.

Second Clipping (on the right side):

• Title: "New Germanic Museum Mural Causes Controversy Again"
• Content Summary: This clipping also discusses the same mural by Rubenstein. It mentions that the mural has caused controversy, with some viewers interpreting it as a criticism of modern warfare and the rise of militarism in Germany. The article notes that the mural depicts figures in contemporary dress, which has led to debates about its intended message. The mural was commissioned by the Germanic Museum and funded by a donation from Mrs. Felix M. Warburg.

Additional Notes:

• The clippings are pasted side by side, with the left one slightly overlapping the right one.
• There are handwritten notes on the page as well, including the date "August, 1934" at the top.
• The text in the clippings is clear and legible, providing detailed context about the mural and its reception.

The overall theme of the clippings is the controversy surrounding the mural and its interpretation as a commentary on German militarism and warfare.

The image shows a newspaper article from the Christian Science Monitor dated September 30, 1933. The article discusses controversy surrounding murals painted by artist George Robert Ruebsamen in Harvard University's Germanic Museum (now known as the Busch-Reisinger Museum).

Key Points:

Headline:
"See Harvard Mural as Slap at Germany"

Subheadline:
"War Techniques in Second Ruebsamen Painting"

Content Summary:

1. Controversial Murals:

   • The article describes two murals in Harvard's Germanic Museum, both of which have sparked controversy.
   • The first mural was criticized last year for its depiction of unclothed figures, which some found inappropriate.
   • The mural portrays "The Gods Clamed to be Rebuked in Nazi Germany," showing a scene with military figures and unclothed individuals.

2. Second Mural:

   • The second mural, titled "The Twilight of the Nibelungen," depicts a group of men in medieval armor, some of whom are unclothed.
   • This mural is said to show a Norse legend where a group of warriors prepares for war and includes a scene where they swear an oath on their weapons.
   • The controversy revolves around the depiction of the figures and the perceived glorification of warlike behavior.

3. Reactions:

   • The article mentions that Nazi sympathizers, specifically members of the Friends of New Germany organization, have rebuked the murals.
   • The depiction of the "Nibelungen" group has been interpreted as a criticism of modern Germany, especially given the political climate at the time.
   • The museum's curator, Charles L. Kuhn, has defended the murals, stating that they are based on a Norse legend and were created to represent courage and loyalty rather than any political statement.

4. Additional Information:

   • The article explains that the controversy has led to protests and a request for the murals to be removed.
   • It also provides background on the groups depicted in the murals, such as the Crusaders and another group showing modern German workers.

Overall, the article highlights the cultural and political tensions surrounding these artworks during that period.

The image shows a book with newspaper clippings and handwritten annotations related to a Harvard University mural by artist Philip Rust Benjamin. The clippings discuss the controversy surrounding two murals painted in the Germanic Museum at Harvard University.

1. Headline and Main Article:

   • The headline reads: "SEE HARVARD MURAL AS SLAP AT GERMANY."
   • The article describes two murals by Benjamin that depict war techniques, specifically focusing on the second mural, "The Ring of the Nibelungen."
   • The mural portrays an undergraduating body with military elements like helmets, armor, and weapons. It is described as an attack on German militarism and is interpreted as a slap at Germany.

2. Controversy:

   • The clippings highlight controversy due to the perceived anti-German sentiment in the murals.
   • One section of the mural depicts a Norse figure leading a group of men with a dwarf and a group of warriors wearing military breaches and helmets.
   • Another section shows a Norse god, Thor, fighting with a group of men, some of whom are described as crusaders.

3. Reactions and Responses:

   • The articles mention reactions from different groups, including the Harvard German Club, which is offended by the portrayal of Germans as "helmeted brutes."
   • The Harvard Crimson newspaper also reports on the controversy, suggesting that the murals are not anti-German but rather represent the forces of good fighting against evil.

4. Annotations:

   • There are handwritten notes and dates (such as "Crumson Oct 14" and "Geb Oct 14") on the clippings, indicating the sources and dates of the articles.
   • The annotations suggest that the clippings are from the Harvard Crimson newspaper.

5. Additional Clippings:

   • One clipping mentions a new German museum mural causing controversy again, depicting a scene where a Norse figure leads a group of men against another group with ancient armor.

The overall theme of the clippings and annotations is the controversy and differing interpretations of Benjamin's murals at Harvard University, particularly their depiction of military themes and their perceived anti-German sentiment.

This image shows an open book with two newspaper articles pasted onto the right and left pages. The book appears to be a scrapbook or a collection of articles, as indicated by the handwritten note in ink at the top left corner, which seems to say 'See Harvard Mural [...] October'. There's also a handwritten annotation on the right page in the same ink, but it is not fully legible.

On the left-hand side, the larger article is headlined "SEE HARVARD MURAL AS SLAP AT GERMANY" with a subheading that reads "War Techniques in Second Rubenstein Painting". Below the headline is the continuation of an article discussing mural techniques which have been found in war technology, referencing a particular mural at Harvard University made by a Harvard graduate and mentioning that "The mural painted over an arch three feet outside the auditorium by careful chiselling".

On the right-hand side, two parts of related articles are visible. The visible headline on the upper right side reads "MURAL CAUSES TROUBLE IN GERMANIC MUSEUM" with subheading "Painting Depicting 'The Twilight of the Gods' Claimed to Be Rebuke to National Germany". The lower part is titled "New Germanic Museum Mural Causes Controversies Again," which is a continuation of the article above.

The visible text talks about the controversy regarding a mural that seems to depict an event or narrative that may be interpreted as critical of the German nationalistic sentiment of that period, possibly referencing the volatile political climate of the time. There are mentions of Wagnerian subjects, Norse gods, and symbolisms relating to power struggles and moral themes.

Overall, the image gives an impression of historical research or collection, with articles possibly dating back to the mid-20th century, given the references to war and the cultural context being discussed.

The image shows an open book with several newspaper clippings attached to its pages. The clippings are organized across two pages and focus on a controversial mural at Harvard University's Germanic Museum.

1. The first clipping, titled "SEE HARVARD MURAL AS SLAP AT GERMANY," discusses how the mural, depicting German war techniques, has been viewed as a rebuke to Nazi Germany.

2. The second clipping, titled "MURAL CAUSES TROUBLE IN GERMANIC MUSEUM," further elaborates on the controversy surrounding the mural, which is part of a series of paintings named "The Twilight of the Gods." It describes the community's reaction to the mural and its perceived anti-Nazi sentiments.

3. The third clipping, titled "New Germanic Museum Mural Causes Controversies Again," covers additional details about the controversies linked to the mural, elaborating on the themes represented in the painting, such as the modern dress of the depicted figures and their symbolic actions.

The clippings have handwritten notes, such as "Crimson Oct 14," likely indicating the date of the articles or their relevance.

A book is open to a page with a headline that reads "SEE HARVARD MURAL AS SLAP AT GERMANY" and a subheading that reads "War Techniques in Second Rubenstein Painting." The article discusses a mural by Harvard University's art professor, Charles L. Rubenstein, that has caused controversy due to its depiction of Nazi Germany. The article includes a photo of the mural, which shows a group of knights attacking a church with weapons, and a quote from Rubenstein, who says that the mural was not meant to be a depiction of the Nazis.

The book is opened, and the pages are facing each other. The book is placed on a white surface. The book is opened on the left side, and it is a newspaper clipping with the text "SEE HARVARD MURAL AS SLAP AT GERMANY." The newspaper clipping is pasted on the book. The right side of the book is blank. The book is placed on a white surface.